What If?

[kingwood313]

I couldnt get anyone to answer this question inside the thread I was posting in so I'll try it here. Since alot of you think Suh gets a bad rap. What if he was this aggressive or dirty towards Matt or Shawn in practice? What if he stepped on Sims arm would you cover for him then or would you consider him dirty.

[Lionsfanfromsac]

He'd be suspended if he tried this against staff (if it happened multiple times). If it happened to Shawn... They'd tell him to toughen up.

Seriously, Suh wouldn't hurt his QB. So I'm not really sure what your trying to get at?

[JWO35]

That means Suh is color blind...

[kingwood313]

Im just curious if people would be so sympathetic with suh if he was laying hands on matt in practice. I guess people didnt see him throw colt mccoy for 8 yards or the crazy neck twister of delhome or his numerous ones one cutler. People dont care but as soon as someone looks at matt wrong people complain.

[madhador]

He'd be suspended if he tried this against staff (if it happened multiple times). If it happened to Shawn... They'd tell him to toughen up.

Seriously, Suh wouldn't hurt his QB. So I'm not really sure what your trying to get at?

He's attempting to be the all seeing, all knowing, moral compass of PSD. In the end, I can't tell if kingwood is just a person who love hyperbole far, far too much or is truly a fan of another team but just trolls as a Lions fan. I could buy into either.

With that said, no one has ever knocked Suh as a locker room cancer, he hates opposing players, and I wouldn't want it any other way. The 'new' NFL fans who hate any sort of aggression or passion from defensive players and really want a wimpy sport are the ones who hate him.

[kingwood313]

He's attempting to be the all seeing, all knowing, moral compass of PSD. In the end, I can't tell if kingwood is just a person who love hyperbole far, far too much or is truly a fan of another team but just trolls as a Lions fan. I could buy into either.

With that said, no one has ever knocked Suh as a locker room cancer, he hates opposing players, and I wouldn't want it any other way. The 'new' NFL fans who hate any sort of aggression or passion from defensive players and really want a wimpy sport are the ones who hate him.

everything you just said was pointless bottom line is I been a lions fan proble longer than you. How can try and clown me when I state the obvious suh is a dirty player

[****ed in DET]

kingwood,

The problem is that your argument is flawed. One thing is not the other. This is a Red Herring fallacy. If Suh crapped in his cereal every morning and then ate it, that would be twisted but it still wouldn't help us consider how he is playing football on Sunday.

Similarly, if he is acting crazy in practice (which he is not) it wouldn't have anything to do with kicking Stump the Schaub in the nuts.

What if the media stirs the pot whenever Suh is involved because it sells? Suh is a freak of nature and people are interested by him. Is it possible that the people who get paid to stir the emotions of the audience are trying to fan the flames whenever Suh does something? It would make sense. If their opinions elicit a reaction from the audience, it helps them keep their job and could even advance their career.

[det32]

I couldnt get anyone to answer this question inside the thread I was posting in so I'll try it here. Since alot of you think Suh gets a bad rap. What if he was this aggressive or dirty towards Matt or Shawn in practice? What if he stepped on Sims arm would you cover for him then or would you consider him dirty.

it did get answered... hill and stafford are red shirt... and the dont go full blow like that in practice..

in a game he is playing to win.. in practice he is playing to get better and the OL better

he isnt dirty at all he is playing how football should be played


and if sims kept being a *** and untiring his shoes ****ing with him i wouldnt have a problem with him retailating

[kingwood313]

it did get answered... hill and stafford are red shirt... and the dont go full blow like that in practice..

in a game he is playing to win.. in practice he is playing to get better and the OL better

he isnt dirty at all he is playing how football should be played


and if sims kept being a *** and untiring his shoes ****ing with him i wouldnt have a problem with him retailating

ok although I dont agree with your answer at least you answered it. and once again I go to lions practice I know what color the jersey is thats why I said what if suh hits stafford like that the key words what if

[det32]

everything you just said was pointless bottom line is I been a lions fan proble longer than you. How can try and clown me when I state the obvious suh is a dirty player

no it reallly wasnt..

he sid he dosnt do that agenst his own teamates.. he hates the other team... nothing wrong with that..

untill reports comeout that suh is doing this to his teamates you have no ground to your argument

[det32]

i donno what happens is suh or any player acadentley hits the red shirt... sent home? run laps? ear full?

the point we have no reason to belive he would hit stafford like he does other QBs..

he is not playing to win in practices.. so why gun might yell that the presser was shity its not a big deal stafford got the pass off in time


a much better argument would have been hinting the RB to hard in witch case you could chop it up to adrenalin.. i just find it hard to believe suh would do anything to harm a teammate when we haven't heard anything remotely close to that from his teammates

there was a report that said he like to keep to him self tho.. but who gives a ****?

[kingwood313]

no it reallly wasnt..

he sid he dosnt do that agenst his own teamates.. he hates the other team... nothing wrong with that..

untill reports comeout that suh is doing this to his teamates you have no ground to your argument

so det 32 go on you tube and look at suh's hits on mccoy in college missouri qb his hits and forearm on cutler and his jake delhome neck twister and tell me if you was any of there coaches would you be mad. most of you guys have tunnel vision and hopes he hurts some one

[kingwood313]

ok lets just say monday he gets a one game suspension how many more suspensions will he have to get before you say he needs to calm down. Or will you always think the league against him

[****ed in DET]

I believe he is unfairly judged.

[det32]

so det 32 go on you tube and look at suh's hits on mccoy in college missouri qb his hits and forearm on cutler and his jake delhome neck twister and tell me if you was any of there coaches would you be mad. most of you guys have tunnel vision and hopes he hurts some one

its football i love the hits.. correct me if i am wrong all of them got up..

suresley dude if you want to watch flag football go for it... the hits are waht make it worth it... even if its our guys i love seeing someone take a big hit

o and the cutler forarm was leagle