2013 Blue Jays Trade Idea Thread

[armchairgm]

Not that it's happening however trade value wise would TDA, Sanchez and Syndergaard be enough for Stanton of the Marlins. I'm not proposing trade just trying to understand what people think it would take to trade for Stanton. Not sure if ever a player this good and young has ever been traded???????

[albertajaysfan]

Not that it's happening however trade value wise would TDA, Sanchez and Syndergaard be enough for Stanton of the Marlins. I'm not proposing trade just trying to understand what people think it would take to trade for Stanton. Not sure if ever a player this good and young has ever been traded???????

It really depends on what the Marlins would be looking for in return. To be honest though unless Stanton forces his way out he doesn't get traded until he starts making piles of money in arbitration.

Even the Marlins FO isn't stupid enough that the last 8 fans would cancel their season tickets if they traded Stanton. Nolasco and him are the only useful major leaguers they have left from last year. Nolasco they could get away with trading as long as they get something in return.

Sidenote: I do not include LoMo in that discussion until he proves otherwise.

Edit: realized I never really answered your question. I would guess that would be the type of package necessary to get Stanton.

[wagnall]

It really depends on what the Marlins would be looking for in return. To be honest though unless Stanton forces his way out he doesn't get traded until he starts making piles of money in arbitration.

Even the Marlins FO isn't stupid enough that the last 8 fans would cancel their season tickets if they traded Stanton. Nolasco and him are the only useful major leaguers they have left from last year. Nolasco they could get away with trading as long as they get something in return.

Sidenote: I do not include LoMo in that discussion until he proves otherwise.

Edit: realized I never really answered your question. I would guess that would be the type of package necessary to get Stanton.

Your giving Loria way too much credit here...

[Sanyo]

^ Agreed.

[Iggy]

Although this trade would probably never happen it seems fair to me ... KC may want another B prospect from NYMets and/or the Jays

NYMets get D'Arnaud give up Z.Wheeler
KC gets Wheeler give up W.Myer
Tor gets Myer gives up D'Arnaud

Mets get the quality catcher they need KC gets the starting pitcher they are looking for and Myer is a great prospect that could play some DH and outfield especially if Rasmus was traded

[LanceUpperCut]

Although this trade would probably never happen it seems fair to me ... KC may want another B prospect from NYMets and/or the Jays

NYMets get D'Arnaud give up Z.Wheeler
KC gets Wheeler give up W.Myer
Tor gets Myer gives up D'Arnaud

Mets get the quality catcher they need KC gets the starting pitcher they are looking for and Myer is a great prospect that could play some DH and outfield especially if Rasmus was traded

It seems pretty fair but us and the Mets might have to add a little considering Myers is probably the best guy in the deal.

[PeterH]

Myer is being discussed in a deal for Lester

[Krylian]

Myer is good.

Myers is better.

[wamco]

too bad they wouldn't take buehrle for him

[GNick]

Although this trade would probably never happen it seems fair to me ... KC may want another B prospect from NYMets and/or the Jays

NYMets get D'Arnaud give up Z.Wheeler
KC gets Wheeler give up W.Myer
Tor gets Myer gives up D'Arnaud

Mets get the quality catcher they need KC gets the starting pitcher they are looking for and Myer is a great prospect that could play some DH and outfield especially if Rasmus was traded

Why deal best catching prospect for best outfield prospect? Catcher has more intrinsic value to club

[GNick]

Not that it's happening however trade value wise would TDA, Sanchez and Syndergaard be enough for Stanton of the Marlins. I'm not proposing trade just trying to understand what people think it would take to trade for Stanton. Not sure if ever a player this good and young has ever been traded???????

Doubtful....Stanton not the type of player Marlins be ready to move.

I'd like to do a Santos/Molina type trades again, where we deal one of our top prospects, just this time for another starter.

[Halladay]

Why deal best catching prospect for best outfield prospect? Catcher has more intrinsic value to club

You generally wouldn't but at the same time, catchers break down and are harder to project. I agree though, outfielders are generally a dime a dozen, very easy to find, very easy to replace. Every farm system in baseball seems to have 2 or 3 pretty good ones.

[Sanyo]

Trading prospects means nothing. You never see a team trading purely prospects -- I cant even remember if a trade has ever been done with just prospects...

[statquo]

Brett Wallace for Anthony gose

[Sanyo]

Brett Wallace for Anthony gose

Touche.

That and Michael Taylor for Brett Wallace

But its still very rare...