Willingham-G/281, H/255, 2B/56, 3B/1, HR/64, RBI/208, BB/132, SO/291
Trumbo -G/293, H/283, 2B/50, 3B/4, HR/61, RBI/182, BB/61, SO/273
And although I will give you that Willinghams "WAR" of last year was better, you have to consider he set career highs in HRs, RBIs, BBs, Slug, Ops, and tied his career high in OBP. Factor into the equation that Trumbo is seven years younger and would be a staple in our offense for years to come, not just the next two years. I would personally prefer Trumbo, even if it did cost a little more.