One of the Biggest Hall of Fame Classes to date: Discussion and vote thread

[Jeffy25]

for those that want to argue against Curt Schilling. It's interesting to point out that he has the greatest K/BB of all time.

4.38

[bagwell368]

for those that want to argue against Curt Schilling. It's interesting to point out that he has the greatest K/BB of all time.

4.38

Schilling's rate stats, playoff performances, and unordered peak puts him well into the middle of the pack among HOF pitchers.

He's a sanctimonious jerk, but he's still clearly a HOF.

[Mr Haha]

this is my favorite bonds steroid story:


http://www.sfweekly.com/2007-09-26/n...tells-all/full

It's the same thing as taking greenies and throwing spit balls.

Don't rock the boat. Nothing needs to be taken into account but the NUMBERS, silly.

[homie564]

Either of current players (players still playing) or players in the past up for nomination, who do you believe will be the best player to not eventually make the hall of fame?

[iAugust]

Pete Rose

[PraiseJesus]

Michael Trout

[Jeffy25]

To not eventually make it?

Because Bagwell, Bonds etc will all eventually make it most likely.


That will never make it?

Jackson and Rose are one discussion point

But of eligible players;
Lou Whitaker probably if I could name only one.

[the_jon]

Pete Rose by inifinity... I know that doesn't make sense but neither does Pete Rose not being in the Hall of Fame.

[ciaban]

maybe gil hodges, or maybe Dale Murphy

[Jeffy25]

maybe gil hodges

Gil Hodges?

With Alan Trammel, Lou Whitaker, Larry Walker, Bobby Grich, Tim Raines, Edgar Martinez not in?

Hodges is pretty far down the list, like Omar Vizquel territory.

[VRP723]

Easy. Shoeless Joe.

[SenorGato]

Since Carlos Beltran won't make it, I'm going to go with Carlos Beltran. Carlos Beltran is awesome and was even more awesome.

[nymetsrule]

Tommy John

[Nomar]

Field of Dreams boi

[Cheezombie]

Easy. Shoeless Joe.

This