Extensive QB rankings by division and league comparison

[SenecaValley46]

What im going to do is list the 4 starting QBs from each division in the league. Rate them in regards vs the quarterbacks in each of there rankings around the league. So rate 1-8 for all the divisons 1, 1-8 for all 2s, 1-8 for all 3, 1-8 for all 4.

Clarification the best quarterbacks in each division the way i have them are Brady, Rodgers, Brees, etc. the number next to there names rates them in compairson to the other quarterbacks who are the best in other divisions 1-8... i do the same for the #2 best guys in each division, #3 best guys in each division, and the worst qbs in each division.. so your order of list rates you in how you are in your division, the number next their names rates them how they stand compared to their peers from around the league who are in the same ranking as them across the rest of the leagues divisions (8)

AFC East

Brady 1
Fitzpatrick 8
Tannehill 8
Sanchez 6

AFC North

Roethlisberger 4
Dalton 6
Flacco 5
Weeden 3

AFC South

Luck 7
Schaub 5
Locker 7
Gabbert 8

AFC West

Peyton Manning 3
Rivers 7
Palmer 6
Cassel 7

NFC East

RG 6
Romo 2
Eli Manning (20-15 TD/INT 60%) otherwise would be higher)1
Foles 2

NFC North

Rodgers 2
Stafford 4
Cutler 3
Ponder 4

NFC South

Brees 5
Ryan 1
Newton 2
Freeman 1

NFC West

Wilson 8
Colin Kap 3
Sam Bradford 4
Kolb 5

Kind of time consuming but a completely different way to look at things. When you really break down the league you see the strength of QBs is in the NFC as most of them dominate the rankings vs there peers who are ranked at the same ranking as them across the league

[FortDetroit]

im so confused.

EDIT: nvm i get it.

[NoUseForAName]

I dont get it

[subroc]

What is the point? I am sure you enjoyed the exercise. I am sure coming to some 1-8 judgement on these players gave you a chance to look at them in depth. But, what do you get out of this that a stat line can't tell us? it is a pretty subjective exercise after all?

[SenecaValley46]

What is the point? I am sure you enjoyed the exercise. I am sure coming to some 1-8 judgement on these players gave you a chance to look at them in depth. But, what do you get out of this that a stat line can't tell us? it is a pretty subjective exercise after all?

People can do there own.. its just a different perspective to show the leagues strength of quarterbacks.. actually was kind of fun i assumed a few people may see what i did and do one themselves. theres many points of way of evaluating them to the positions they are in

[Pinstripe power]

might be easier to udnerstand if you did it by ranking, not division. for example

best qb in divison

1) Rodgers
2) Brady
3) Peyton
4) Brees
5) Big Ben
6) RG3
7) Schaub
8) Wilson

2nd best qb in divison

1) Ryan
2) Romo
3) Stafford
4) Rivers
5) Luck
6) Dalton
7) Kapenick
8) Fitpatrick

3rd best qb in divison

1) Eli
2) Culter
3) Newton
4) Flacco
5) Bradford
6) Palmer
7) Tannehill
8) Locker

4th best qb in divison

1) Freeman
2) Weedon
3) Cassel
4) Ponder
5) Kolb
6) Foles
7) Gabbert
8) Sanchez

[Alpha Dog]

How you have Locker ahead of Gabbert? Blaine has better numbers on a poorer team. Plus he was playing through the same injury that shelved Locker for half a season.

[FortDetroit]

How you have Locker ahead of Gabbert? Blaine has better numbers on a poorer team. Plus he was playing through the same injury that shelved Locker for half a season.

the same injury they put him on the IR for?

[Alpha Dog]

the same injury they put him on the IR for?

No, they put him on IR for the forearm injury. That was going to take a long time to heal so they thought they might as well IR Gabbert and do his shoulder surgery so he would be in better shape come next season.

[Pinstripe power]

How you have Locker ahead of Gabbert? Blaine has better numbers on a poorer team. Plus he was playing through the same injury that shelved Locker for half a season.

because gabbert sucks

[Alpha Dog]

because gabbert sucks

Was not talking to you, toad. Go back to chewing your way through that N.Y. smog.

[Pinstripe power]

Was not talking to you, toad. Go back to chewing your way through that N.Y. smog.

i live in baltimore

[Alpha Dog]

i live in baltimore

Sorry, I didn't realize. You just wish you could chew N.Y. smog.

[Pinstripe power]

Sorry, I didn't realize. You just wish you could chew N.Y. smog.

nah I'm pretty happy in baltimore. I also don't wish my team had a half way decent qb, that would be your wish

[Alpha Dog]

nah I'm pretty happy in baltimore. I also don't wish my team had a half way decent qb, that would be your wish

Lurch? Ha ha ha, I wouldn't trade Henne for that robot, much less Gabbert.