If Amare was in Melo's place right now would you want to bench Melo

[STATcityNYK]

For those of you that think Tyson Chandler is better than Amare Stoudemire I question your intelligence seriously

[lowkeymelo]

LOl you mean the team he had when he won MVP of the month? You mean the team with no PG?

amare had Felton, Mozzy, Chandler, Gallo, thats not exactly crap you know.

convienent stats lol

after that they went 6-12 before Melo, or do those games not count? As I said around .500.

Carmelo Anthony is a 3 ...he's the best scorer in the league ...he's also a ball handler ...he was playing the pg and pf ...the team was in his control during that time

& Amaré had Raymond, an inconsistent but still a good good player in gallo , and a wilson chandler who was playing his best ball...not to mention Landry Fields ... the player you guys see amaré as had that team with a 2-9 record then went 19-5 after not to mention those 9 straight 30 point games with that 8-1 record ..shoulda been 9-0 if they didn't cheat against Boston .... question is which team had the better 8-1 run ...this current team or Amaré's team ?

[still a fan]

Ray felt and STAT were the stars of the team stat and Ray's chemistry was at about 100 a inconsistent will the thrill and Gallo werr his core back up could Melo have had that team way over .500 ? Ohh I thought so

you know that Ohh I thought so hurts your post rather than help right?

Its almost like a child in the car saying are we there yet?

As I said before with posts like this I can't converse with you, I tried hard though.

Last thought because this thread has gone south, amare is hurt and it really don't matter if we could or could not switch Melo and Amare.

Right now I'm happy Melo is not hurt, he's the main reason we are 8-1, and if you think differently please read what his teammates and coaching staff and opponents and opponents coaches are saying.

If this continues in this matter the thread will be closed. If your opinion is trying to say something then just say it, but don't ask a question you are not able to handle the response to.

[STATcityNYK]

Everyone acting like the knicks are playing flawless right now but face reality if they are missing all those shots they jack up every game and start losing then what will you say because i'm sure Melo will get all the blame hypocrites

[still a fan]

You don't lose your spot because of injury

tell that to Phil Simms when the Giants won their second superbowl

[still a fan]

Everyone acting like the knicks are playing flawless right now but face reality if they are missing all those shots they jack up every game and start losing then what will you say because i'm sure Melo will get all the blame hypocrites

Did you start this thread? Is it about the Knicks being flawless or about switching Amare and Melo?

Where are you going, do you know?

Can we talk Knick basketball about things going on tonight or something that might or might not happen in over a month?

I hope its talk Knicks basketball about whats going on for real in the present

[LOOTERX9]

For those of you that think Tyson Chandler is better than Amare Stoudemire I question your intelligence seriously

Tyson is far more important to a championship team than Amare was, is, or ever will be. That's how I look at it. I already know that amare will mess up the usefullness of tyson when he comes back, so i hope amare is out the entire season. It does 2 things by making melo play the PF and keeps tyson involved offensively.

[STATcityNYK]

you know that Ohh I thought so hurts your post rather than help right?

Its almost like a child in the car saying are we there yet?

As I said before with posts like this I can't converse with you, I tried hard though.

Last thought because this thread has gone south, amare is hurt and it really don't matter if we could or could not switch Melo and Amare.

Right now I'm happy Melo is not hurt, he's the main reason we are 8-1, and if you think differently please read what his teammates and coaching staff and opponents and opponents coaches are saying.

If this continues in this matter the thread will be closed. If your opinion is trying to say something then just say it, but don't ask a question you are not able to handle the response to.

I'm not scared of the truth the truth is they wouldn't be a good team there not needing a response I question your intelligence you read and see what you want to see w/o answering the question before you

[bofakop]

Tyson is far more important to a championship team than Amare was, is, or ever will be. That's how I look at it. I already know that amare will mess up the usefullness of tyson when he comes back, so i hope amare is out the entire season. It does 2 things by making melo play the PF and keeps tyson involved offensively.

Wow.... thats a record for you how many pages of an Amare thread....and this is first comment from you??? I am disappointed in you!!

[still a fan]

okay this thread has ran it course.

Knicks vs Mav's , lets keep rolling.