49ers QB Thread V 1

[Lakers211221]

I can say the same thing on just about every game Alex has played the last couple of years.



Trust me, I don't forget about the bad games. And I don't just focus per say on the last 2 games for Kaep. But, I can say that the Saint's game wasn't all that from Kaep either, so honestly he's had 1 real good game against the Bears, 3 So-So games - but with one being in the Superdome, at least that one has a lot more reasons and not as many excuses.

BUT... we're 3-1-1 with Kaep right now (you gotta put his finger prints on that tie game too). So I'm not PO'd about that, but I think it could be better... and honestly I'm VERY worried about the next 2 games.

I don't think you put the tie on Kap. The 49ers were down 7 when he took over.

[OREcoast49er]

CK run fast

[Lakers211221]

Year 	Team 	G 	Att 	Comp 	Pct 	Att/G 	Yds 	Avg 	Yds/G 	TD 	TD% 	Int 	Int% 	Lng 	20+ 	40+ 	Sck 	SckY 	Rate
2012 	49ers 	10 	129 	87 	67.4 	12.9 	1,073 	8.3 	107.3 	3 	2.3 	1 	0.8 	57 	16 	3 	13 	82 	97.5

Year 	Team 	G 	Att 	Comp 	Pct 	Att/G 	Yds 	Avg 	Yds/G 	TD 	TD% 	Int 	Int% 	Lng 	20+ 	40+ 	Sck 	SckY 	Rate
2012 	49ers 	9 	217 	152 	70.0 	24.1 	1,731 	8.0 	192.3 	13 	6.0 	5 	2.3 	55 	22 	4 	24 	137 	104.1

BTW, YTD numbers for both QB's. I've bolded a few that I think are the most important and stand out the most in their numbers.

Those #s are basically the same. Also, TD% and QB Rating don't take into account Kap's rushing TDs. If you use QBR instead of QB Rating, Kap is higher than Alex. And, Kap hasn't had the chance to play home games versus the Bills and Cards to pad his stats.

[bigcheeze]

I don't think you put the tie on Kap. The 49ers were down 7 when he took over.

Sorry, but he played 4 quarters of the 5 quarter game. He had his part in that game, I'm not BLAMING him, but it has his fingerprints on that game.

[bigcheeze]

Those #s are basically the same. Also, TD% and QB Rating don't take into account Kap's rushing TDs. If you use QBR instead of QB Rating, Kap is higher than Alex. And, Kap hasn't had the chance to play home games versus the Bills and Cards to pad his stats.

Hey I'm just giving you the number we have to compare. I can't make comments about things that could have happened. These numbers are what these numbers are.

[Lakers211221]

Sorry, but he played 4 quarters of the 5 quarter game. He had his part in that game, I'm not BLAMING him, but it has his fingerprints on that game.

He started the game down 7. If you take Alex's part out, Kap won by 7 in regulation.

[Lakers211221]

Hey I'm just giving you the number we have to compare. I can't make comments about things that could have happened. These numbers are what these numbers are.

Right, and the #s are essentially identical. And if you consider the opponents that both players played, then an argument can be made in Kap's favor.

[hd1906]

This argument is getting tired, let Kaep play 7 seasons and well see who's better..Kaep is the starter btw in case those of u still unsure haven't noticed..so shoulda coulda woulda is isn't won't will....

Let kaep play another season, or hell, let him finish this season for gods sake before you start parading his small sample size against a larger crappy sample size of Alex smith..

Go Niners btw!!

[Kyle916]

At this point I just look forward to the day when the season is over and we move on so all fans can drop this whole pointless argument.

[OREcoast49er]

CK will be fine when Roman gets his **** together.

[OREcoast49er]

At this point I just look forward to the day when the season is over and we move on so all fans can drop this whole pointless argument.

Hopefully it ends in February with a smile on our faces

[lolPhillies]

At this point I just look forward to the day when the season is over and we move on so all fans can drop this whole pointless argument.

Agreed.

CK will be fine when Roman gets his **** together.

Hope so.

[NinerHomer49]

CK will be fine when Roman gets his **** together.

Agreed. The problem though...he thinks he already does so I'm pretty concerned that nothing will change.

[bigcheeze]

Hopefully it ends in February with a smile on our faces

Me too.

[lolPhillies]

Me too.

x3.