Romo vs Eli?

[DavidR]

I can't stand either QB. But I would rather have Eli then Romoception.

[Mr Haha]

In November against the Browns, Romo every time.

[el hidalgo]

Eli > Choke-mo anyday

[Pinstripe pride]

LOL - the playoff tournament features the best teams. The record speaks for itself and includes 7 road playoff wins as an underdog and two Superbowl MVP's over Tom Brady, including the undefeated Pats. Put that resume against Romo. It's Eli by a landslide and isn't even close.

the 7-9 seahwaks made it over 2 10 win teams. that is clearly not always the case

[NYSPORTS98]

the 7-9 seahwaks made it over 2 10 win teams. that is clearly not always the case

Wow, great position. 99.9% historically wrong but you likely will defend that position 100%. No surprise you didn't mention the rest of the post. This debate is as weak as the Eli/Romo debate. Game, Set, Match

[Pinstripe pride]

Wow, great position. 99.9% historically wrong but you likely will defend that position 100%. No surprise you didn't mention the rest of the post. This debate is as weak as the Eli/Romo debate. Game, Set, Match

first, i didnt sya it always happens, i just pointed out that your point is not 100% true as you seme to make it sound.


seocnd, i didnt address the second part because you are using 8 games of eli's career as a comaprison, which is stupid

[NYSPORTS98]

first, i didnt sya it always happens, i just pointed out that your point is not 100% true as you seme to make it sound.


seocnd, i didnt address the second part because you are using 8 games of eli's career as a comaprison, which is stupid

Dismissing the post season is comical and is certainly more fantasy and hatred/jealousy driven than football driven. Picking one 7-9 team is a bit anal.

[Pinstripe pride]

Dismissing the post season is comical and is certainly more fantasy and hatred/jealousy driven than football driven. Picking one 7-9 team is a bit anal.

i'm not dimissing it, i'm just not using it as the entire and sole basis of my arguement like you do. to me its one of many factors, to you its the only factor

[NYSPORTS98]

i'm not dimissing it, i'm just not using it as the entire and sole basis of my arguement like you do. to me its one of many factors, to you its the only factor

Wrong again. The 7-9 comment was anal. We all know a certain minority from small towns have issues the big city. We get it. As far as this debate, it was over back in 2008. Now it's just a fantasy joke

[Pinstripe pride]

Wrong again. The 7-9 comment was anal. We all know a certain minority from small towns have issues the big city. We get it. As far as this debate, it was over back in 2008. Now it's just a fantasy joke

how is that anal? thats not the first time an i ferior team made it in over a better one ebcause of a weak division. its just the best example

[Gandalf]

Eli is much better is then even a question

[Jack of Blades]

Eli is much better is then even a question

I disagree so yes it is a question.

[rawz]

Eli is much better is then even a question

I disagree so yes it is a question.

you cant argue that. There is certainly a question. If not, why would there be a thread? You dont see many, "which is bigger, a whale or a fly" threads. cause thats not even a question. the whale is bigger.....

but has far has eli vs romo, it goes back and forth.

romo, better stats, eli, 2 superbowls, eli better team, better defense, romo doing more with less, better girlfriends, etc.

seriously, its close.

[Mr Haha]

you cant argue that. There is certainly a question. If not, why would there be a thread? You dont see many, "which is bigger, a whale or a fly" threads. cause thats not even a question. the whale is bigger.....

but has far has eli vs romo, it goes back and forth.

romo, better stats, eli, 2 superbowls, eli better team, better defense, romo doing more with less, better girlfriends, etc.

seriously, its close.

All I ever hear during the offseason is how stacked the Cowboys are with talent. It's annual. To say Romo hasn't had the pieces is just a sad attempt to keep this argument alive. More with less? How about an undrafted WR from Massachusetts? And the many other nobodies Eli has turned into stars?

And I'd take Eli's one wife over Romo's playboy life. I like the QB of my team watching film and practicing during the playoff bye week you spent all year earning instead of taking Jessica Simpson to Mexico.

But, as always, I'll defer to Jerry Jones in this debate.

"What's the difference between us and them? Eli Manning."
-Jerry Jones.

[d79cheese]

All I ever hear during the offseason is how stacked the Cowboys are with talent. It's annual. To say Romo hasn't had the pieces is just a sad attempt to keep this argument alive. More with less? How about an undrafted WR from Massachusetts? And the many other nobodies Eli has turned into stars?

And I'd take Eli's one wife over Romo's playboy life. I like the QB of my team watching film and practicing during the playoff bye week you spent all year earning instead of taking Jessica Simpson to Mexico.

But, as always, I'll defer to Jerry Jones in this debate.

"What's the difference between us and them? Eli Manning."
-Jerry Jones.

Not gonna get in a pissing match here, but just because ESPN hypes them up every year doesn't mean they have Pro Bowlers all over the place.

I can see you undrafted WR from Mass. and raise you an undrafted WR from Monmouth (Austin). Anyone know how Laurent Robinson is doing this year with Gabbert and Henne?

Eli and Romo have had pretty similar players in skill positions in their career. Both came in with aging WR's as their number 1's (Toomer and Owens), both now have first rounders as big go to guys (Nicks and Bryant), and both have made undrafted guys look like All Pro's at certain points. The only huge difference is that Romo has a star TE in Witten (who was a 3rd rounder and no slam dunk to be this productive), while Eli hasn't had a high profile TE since Shockey.