Yes, Profar looks like a can't miss prospect and everyone wants 2 trade Elvis for Upton. How do we know that Profar will live up to all the hype? I remember Ruben Mateo being a can't miss prospect and we didn't get Roger Clemens from TOR because we wouldn't include him. I believe all the hype too. I think he's going to be an absolute bad *** but you have to be careful what you wish for too.
This is the very question I asked on the board a couple days ago. No one knows because Profar is an unknown quantity. Even if he were proven I say keep he and Elvis both and send Kinsler to first whether he likes it or not.
With this pitching staff we need all the in field help we can get.