There is only 1 ELITE QB in the NFL,period.

[blom85]

Elite should be a combination of this..

Multiple seasons of a qb rating of 100.00 or higher, have several game winning drives, have a championship under they're belt.

Only ones that can be in this catagory are Drew Brees, Arron Rodgers, Peyton Manning, Tom Brady.

The next category are really really good qb's that fall just short of elite depending on the categories i stated above.

Ben Roethlisberger, rating not there...

Eli Manning, rating not there...

Matt Ryan, no ship....

[Bigdaddyburch]

This is not going to go well for you. Fact is Manning is and has only ever been sub par. Brady is the third secondish greatest ever. These are fact that can not be denied by any sane person.

[ManRamForPrez24]

Thanks for sharing your opinion, OP, but that's all it is.

Moving on...

[crzyhawk]

no Gabbert ??

lol

[TheBigCheese21]

PSD is really making me hate Peyton Manning. Lay off the dudes jock already. Some of you act like he is the second coming of Jesus Christ or some ****. Can't wait until he effin retires so i don't have to read this crap anymore. I thought the media was bad but leave it to PSD to out do them.

[BigBlueCrew]

PSD is really making me hate Peyton Manning. Lay off the dudes jock already. Some of you act like he is the second coming of Jesus Christ or some ****. Can't wait until he effin retires so i don't have to read this crap anymore. I thought the media was bad but leave it to PSD to out do them.

We're sorry, we'll make Aaron Rodgers the second coming Jesus Christ as you wish

[Bigdaddyburch]

PSD is really making me hate Peyton Manning. Lay off the dudes jock already. Some of you act like he is the second coming of Jesus Christ or some ****. Can't wait until he effin retires so i don't have to read this crap anymore. I thought the media was bad but leave it to PSD to out do them.

I have never seen a average QB talked about so much. Its crazy. You should hear it here. Wish we had Tebow back.

[TheBigCheese21]

We're sorry, we'll make Aaron Rodgers the second coming Jesus Christ as you wish

Did i ask for that? No im not a homer like some of you guys on here. There is a ****ing thread created everyday about how Peyton is the MVP or how he is elite or how he is come back player of the year or how he is the greatest player to ever play the game. **** gets old real quick. I could give two ***** whether posters like you think Rodgers is good or horrible, i just get tired of coming into here and see there is some new thread talking about how great Peyton is. Yes we get it Peyton is good at football.

[iam brett favre]

Rodgers >

[Bigdaddyburch]

Did i ask for that? No im not a homer like some of you guys on here. There is a ****ing thread created everyday about how Peyton is the MVP or how he is elite or how he is come back player of the year or how he is the greatest player to ever play the game. **** gets old real quick. I could give two ***** whether posters like you think Rodgers is good or horrible, i just get tired of coming into here and see there is some new thread talking about how great Peyton is. Yes we get it Peyton is good at football.

BUT he isn't. Rodgers is twice the QB. Dont give in to these guys. Stand your ground.

[BigBlueCrew]

BUT he isn't. Rodgers is twice the QB. Dont give in to these guys. Stand your ground.

really?

oh well..... no response

[TheBigCheese21]

BUT he isn't. Rodgers is twice the QB. Dont give in to these guys. Stand your ground.

Nice try on the trolling. I am pretty sure everyone knows Peyton is one of the greatest to ever play the position but that doesn't mean we need a new thread created every single day reminding us of that. How about someone just creates a PM thread and everyone that love PM can go have their circle jerk in there.

[GGGGG-Men]

The Patriots are a contender for a SB run EVERY SINGLE YEAR and a huge part of that is because of Brady.

Brees could take any team and make them an instant contender.

Rodgers is a damn machine.

Those 3 and Peyton are elite. Peyton just happens to be a mad genius in football and I'd definitely rank him ahead of the others just for his football IQ alone, but they're still all in that class.

[Bigdaddyburch]

Nice try on the trolling. I am pretty sure everyone knows Peyton is one of the greatest to ever play the position but that doesn't mean we need a new thread created every single day reminding us of that. How about someone just creates a PM thread and everyone that love PM can go have their circle jerk in there.

I dont agree. Manning has only won one SB. Guess what so did Trent Dilfer. I am on your side on this. What makes what Manning is doing so special? Give me one reason why? Rodgers is having a even better season.

[TheBigCheese21]

I dont agree. Manning has only won one SB. Guess what so did Trent Dilfer. I am on your side on this. What makes what Manning is doing so special? Give me one reason why? Rodgers is having a even better season.

Rodgers only has 1 SB, Marino had 0 SB's, im not like Giants fans who judge greatness on SB rings. I just hate how everyone is blowing PM just cause he was hurt last year and he came back and is playing pretty good this year. But check the stats people it not like he is leading in every stat possible. But because of his past and because of the injury he is overcoming it automatically makes him MVP apparently.