Bad voting, name them

[Jeffy25]

John Fay of Cincinnati
NL Cy Young
1. Johnny Cueto
2. R.A. Dickey
3. Clayton Kershaw

John Erardi of Cincinnati
NL ROY
1. Todd Frazier
2. Bryce Harper
3. Wade Miley


What is the point in letting them vote if they are just going to vote for their guys?


I am happy that Tom Hardicourt and George King have had their privileges taken away at this point, but what is the point in letting guys that do this continue to vote?

The only first place vote for a guy is from that guys home city? It's clearly a homer vote when that happens.

[utl768]

that moron from espn with the bad hairline who voted for kimbrell

[MetsFanatic19]

Unless thye pick out a select few of sports analysts and nuetral voters, it will always be like this. Whether it's sports reporters in a city, a teammate, or a coach, some people will always vote for their guy and not who deserves it.

[SFrush90]

that moron from espn with the bad hairline who voted for kimbrell

Who dat be?

[JaysFan87]

ohhh **** off drew davidson voted for ****in rodney?? this is why its a falwed system even though i think they got it right this year.

[Jeffy25]

ohhh **** off drew davidson voted for ****in rodney?? this is why its a falwed system even though i think they got it right this year.

Pretty sure he voted Michael Young first place in AL MVP last year

[Jeffy25]

and I meant to say George King in my initial post, who left Pedro off a ballot one year 'because pitchers don't deserve the award' and then voted for David Wells the next year

[JaysFan87]

Pretty sure he voted Michael Young first place in AL MVP last year

different texas guy did that. i forgot his name tho.

[GasMan]

Which is why these awards are meaningless

[TheRazorboy]

Which is why these awards are meaningless

Not to their agents.

[Daaaarryyl]

and I meant to say George King in my initial post, who left Pedro off a ballot one year 'because pitchers don't deserve the award' and then voted for David Wells the next year

I'll never forget that. He was a Yankee beat reporter for the NY Post.

Just a pathetic homer who I hope isn't even a journalist anymore.

[Jeffy25]

I'll never forget that. He was a Yankee beat reporter for the NY Post.

Just a pathetic homer who I hope isn't even a journalist anymore.

And he was obsessed with Jeter

[GasMan]

Not to their agents.

Exactly, and we all know agents only care about the truth.

[Scully in 2012]

The voting system is severally flawed, obviously.

Verlander should have won in the AL

Kershaw should have won in the NL

dickey had a great year but you can't count the W-L column to determine how great a pitcher is.

[Jeffy25]

The voting system is severally flawed, obviously.

Verlander should have won in the AL

Kershaw should have won in the NL

dickey had a great year but you can't count the W-L column to determine how great a pitcher is.

Neither were snubbed, this was a close call between both first and second place winners in both.

The winners are not the issue.