Picking up all-stars in their prime is a panic move?
I'm sorry what? If JJ can stay healthy (which is a coin flip) then he's a all-star pitcher, I'll give you that. Reyes All-Star days are behind him, as some have pointed out the turf is going to give Reyes problems (medically). I wouldn't be shocked to see him with a WAR around 2.5-3 this year. As far as Buehrle goes, he's a bull dog inning eater that will give you 200ip. Is he an "All-Star" pitcher? No but he's a solid #2 and a great #3.