
Originally Posted by
dogdaddy
Don't want to get into the whole who should have been head coach stuff, but lets look what has been going on this year. If your going to suck and make major changes on how this organization runs ..... then do it. Its like we have picked up from last year and got worse. Players are not held accountable. Players are not losing their jobs.
Reggie - Maybe a trade or two to show that nobody is safe. Maybe cut a big name to show that your messing with the wrong guy. Fine someone for showing up to practice 5 minutes late and make sure its on ESPN. Make some noise. Anything.
Allen - Here is my beef with him. No emotion at all. Its summed it up for me when the announcer in the Miami game said after three missed tackles on a TD "Wow those players are going to get an earful from Allen when they get to the sidelines". Right then the camera's went to Allen and the defense was jogging off the field passing him to get to the sideline and not one word. Not even a change of expression. It was like he was listening to music and didn't catch the last play. I seen enough of that watching Cable and Shell stand on the sidelines like statues. You look at all the teams that are in the elite groups over the past years and their coach shows emotion on the sidelines and the players respond and feed off that. If someone like Gruden had a fake field goal against him when getting beat, he would have grabbed the defense and ripped some butt. Not DA, sat back and took it like a little girl. The only emotion DA has shown was when he got lit up in the media for smiling during a butt kicking of a game. Also did you notice the Baltimore coaches with less than two minutes to go in the game was still coaching like it was the second quarter.
So you just want some fire on the sidelines?
This is just a question not intended to provoke a bad response, but have you ever been responsible for supervising a group of people in the completion of a task?
I have, and I've gotten good results both by appearing calm and by being animated. Different things work with different groups and it is the responsibility of the person in charge to make that assessment on an ongoing basis and reevaluate his stance given the specifics of the situation.
There were a series of interviews done after Gruden's departure and Callahan's take over with the heavily veteran roster and most were happy to see Callahan's somewhat laid back approach in contrast to Gruden. Full pad practices and tyrades on the sidelines were wearing thin on some of the veteran players and they weren't that bashful about stating their discontent, but only after Gruden departed.
The point here is that none of us really knows exactly what the proper posture is pertaining to this specific group of players, except that there must be mutual respect, along with the necessary mental and physical tools to get the job done.
I think that our real shortcoming here is the lack of tools but that's just one man's opinion.
We will only know the true effectiveness of McKenzie and Co's leadership if we allow them to proceed as they deem necessary and then evaluate the results after an appropriate amount of time. Three years seems about right......
" I have only three rules, be on time, pay attention, and play like hell on Sunday"
-John Madden