Well I ****ed up, because the way I meant to phrase the question was to only include the Cutler era, knowing that the talent on the 06 offense just was way beyond what we have now, and what we even had in 09-10.
But the question is still, what offensive system would you prefer.
Whoever the OC was when Kramer was here and threw for over 4,000 yds, I would like him. That was the only year when the offensive plays were not all that predictable. I thought we had two WRs with over a 1,000 yds each, iirc.
Every election year a old joke resurfaces that basically goes like this: a man is walking thru the park at night when he is suddenly confronted by a man who points a pistol at his face and says (select any of the following "Nixon or McGovern" "Dole, Clinton, or Perot" "Bush or Gore", etc, etc.). Long silence... then the gunman repeats "Nixon or McGovern" (or whatever). Brief silence then the man who was walking thru the park says "go ahead and shoot!"
Casting my vote for John Shoop. Haha no but seriously, I'm willing to ride this "Tice" thing out for the remainder of the year, and maybe even next year if we start to see some improvement. I like how he is willing to take input from Bates and Cutler and it seems like he is willing to make adjustments as needed. The product is far from polished, but hey.. it's his first time doing this, so I can give him the benefit of the doubt.