The MVP at this point

[HoodedSashSB]

Brady

[odiz]

Lol is this trolling????

He just has trouble formulating an argument when he is so securely fastened to Andrew Lucks nut sack.

[odiz]

SOS is an argument for 11 year olds and college football.

You really think I should vote for Josh Freeman for MVP? He's hot garbage. Luck is good.

You cant actually believe that can you? So throwing for 300 yards and 3 TDs against the Bills is no different than doing the same against the Bears or Texans, right?

Glad you set everyone straight about Freeman, that is a great argument. Now we know.

[Bigdaddyburch]

Brady

I am with you. There really is no one even close at this point. I see 15 votes for Manning I have to laugh. What has this guy done? He is only winning because of the team around him.

[BcEuAbRsS]

Dwayne Bowe for not murdering dozens of people.

[BcEuAbRsS]

But in reality, Peyton or Rodgers.

[natelpete]

Adrian Peterson should be on this list.

1. Manning
2. Peterson
3. Ryan
4. Roethlisberger
5. Rodgers
6. Brady

Luck MVP talk is premature. If the Colts keep it up and make the playoffs, than maybe...but right now he isn't in my top 10.

Peyton will win it. The Broncos' schedule is a cupcake from here on out. They could go 12-4 or even 13-3 and I wouldn't be stunned. They lost 3 of their 4 tough games this season, but there's only one more left (@ Baltimore).

This looks good to me.

[HowFit]

If the vote was today, it would be close among top 3-4 qbs, not mentioning Peterson, I would say Peyton...

[lolollort]

seems legit

[Pinstripe power]

peppers

[Pinstripe power]

Seriosuly though, I would have to sya rodgers. he's been phenomenal this year and has had major injuries all of the place. That being said, it probally will be peyton.


Luck should get some consideration too though. He inherited a 2-14 team last year and has them sitting good for a playoff spot right now.

[bosox3431]

You laughed at the notion of Ryan being up there though. Then you're dissecting how they beat Denver to make the other guys look better, as if the other candidates have not barely scraped by good teams by or lost to teams that they should have handled fairly easily. All three teams have talented pass catchers. The Falcons defense has gotten by with forcing turnovers, I know you don't believe they have a better defense than the Broncos or Packers so I won't ask.

If you think Rodgers and Manning are superior to Ryan based on track record prior to this season, that's one thing and I agree with you. But to laugh at his 2012 credentials for an award based on the 2012 season is strange. There is a case for all of them. The laughter should be reserved for [insert other QB that everyone hyped up who hasn't quite lived up to expectations] because a lot of folks predicted the Falcons would finish last in the NFCS.

Theyre superior this year. Plain and simple. What makes either defense better then the falcons. Falcons have allowed less points then both. And the packers live off turnovers to, although not as much this year. And no, their pass rushers arent as good as atlantas, especially denver. If jennings was healthy, I would agree. But with jennings and nelson out its really not close. Im a huge packers fan, but theyre receiiving core is slightly overrated by other fans.

[Tayzak15]

How can it not be Rodgers? lets make a list of injured starters on that team..
-Jennings
-Nelson
-Driver
-Finley
-Benson
-Kuhn-
-Raji
-Shields
-Woodson
-Bishop
-Bulaga
-Matthews

Rodgers is literally carrying this team on his shoulders, winning 4 in a row with 4 of his 6 Main Targets!! being injured. I really don't think its close. MVP is for the player that has the most "VALUE" to the team. Where would the packers be without Rodgers and all those injuries? Probly 1-8 or 2-7. We have already seen what the Broncos can do without Peyton.

[Tayzak15]

bump

[cuttydoesit6]

tillman