Ok the title says it all. Now here is the reason behind the thread. I was visiting a friend at work today and his boss was there, his boss is an avid Viking fan and my buddy is a packers fan. We got on the subject of football, naturally and the Viking fan said the stupidest thing: Clay Matthews was completely overrated because the Pa meds move him all over the field, if he would just go from one spot he would be horrible.
So that got me thinking what was the dumbest reason a player was overrated, any player not just a packer player, past or present, NFL or college.