I really can't tell what all of you guys are shouting at each other about, but these are the Gold Glove awards. They are just about the most useless set of awards in all of sports. And even arguing about them from any objective point of view is really difficult, since defensive stats, while very useful, are not precise enough to compare one very good defender to another very good defender. And as some have pointed out, there are only rudimentary metrics to assess defensive abilities other than range, like arm strength, or in Freeman's case, scooping bad throws from infielders.
We can probably all agree on the only thing that's really relevant here: the Gold Gloves aren't relevant.