Yeah it's called overrated IMO.
Yeah it's called overrated IMO.
whos got more value v-cat or triunfel
wow is this where this thread is going?
some real stuff needs to happen.
I would say both of their values are pretty close to bottom.
I think Cats is higher tho. He was awesome last year. I don't think one down year negates all that.
he had great OPB and slugging
but now his value is minimal for sure. better just to keep him and see if he can rebound, he wont be a major part in a deal
Upton put us on his no trade. Could mean he doesn't want to be here, but could also mean he wants leverage if we do trade for him.
Either way, it may mean we are showing interest and he knows it.
if upton put us on his no trade list, it means we cross him off the list, highly doubtful hes trying to use any psychology w/ that move. if we signed his brother i bet he takes us off tho.
anyways, i feel good that GMZ has reached out to hamilton, AZ about upton.... sounds like neither went far at all, it is on the other party to circle back if something changes but Ms need to go forward in reality. those 2 are not coming here.
MLB network just said upton prolly stays and AZ are shopping kubel who is coming off a banner year.
Last edited by Rain City; 11-19-2012 at 06:54 PM.
Why? You realize he had the Yanks on their too right? It could very well be to get some leverage for a bonus so he takes us off.
Either way, it tells me we were talking about it.
They were both awful last year, but i would argue that the fact that Cat had an elite offensive season before, that he has more value. Triunfel has really never put it together, whereas VCat has.
If you want to talk about how they did at the same level, look at Triunfel at AA compared to VCat. .334 wOBA/98 wRC+ one year, .286/68 the other. Compared to .457/180 for VCat
Thats a BS argument. If he wasnt playing SS, he would have put up unheard of numbers? Really? He created 32% less runs than average one year. I highly doubt if he would have focused more on his offense like you say, he would have gotten anywhere near VCat.
Creating 80% more runs that average doesnt mean anything? Getting even better from the offensive haven in HD to Jackson doesnt mean anything?
I also havent heard about his "premium defense". Ive heard he is pretty average there.
Also, two years earlier? VCat has only been in the minors for 3.5 years, and was in AA in his second. You are gonna try to punish him for getting drafted later. Triunfel has only been above average offensively once in 5 MiLB seasons. VCat was well above average in 3/4
Cmon dude. I dont even understand where you got that stuff. Grasping at some serious straws there.
Last edited by jej; 11-19-2012 at 08:28 PM.
It's not because he was "focusing on defense." The point was (and someone tell me if it wasn't clear) that Triunfel has been young for every league he's played in, that he has been way more challenged than Catricala at earlier stages, and that Catricala has been old for his leagues. In other words, if Triunfel got to hit in High Desert at age 22, he probably would have torn that league a new one. Triunfel was facing better pitching at age 19 than Catricala was at 22.
The other point was that he plays a premium defensive position, SS. VCat is a corner OF if he's lucky by most accounts. In other words, Triunfel outhit Catricala at AAA while being a year and a half younger and being way more valuable defensively. There's an article on Fangraphs that explains why the author believes Elvis Andrus is more valuable than Justin Upton. Position weighs into that belief a lot. Same principle here, plus age, plus recent performance.