Wonder if JZ has something big brewing this off season and Montero, is part of it. I bet Butler is his replacement, at the DH spot.
Wonder if JZ has something big brewing this off season and Montero, is part of it. I bet Butler is his replacement, at the DH spot.
Playstation 3 handle: Ryde4Life
Sponsored Links |
|
ugh if we trade one of the big three for Butler id be pretty disappointed
i just dont think he is worth one of them
^ agree but at the same time it might be the best we can do.
Mauer+ sure. The other 3 not worth it imo, he is under a good amount of team control though
its just a lot for a DH only to me
Butler is one of my favorites, but bringing him in means giving up on/trading one of Smoak and Montero, and I'm not ready to do that.
I don't want to see Montero traded, but it could happen if we get Butler. Trading him could come back to haunt us, bad.
Yep. I agree Jej. We cannot give up on Montero.
he has an MVP ceiling.
Sponsored Links |
|
I don't wanna trade montero either.
Playstation 3 handle: Ryde4Life
I'd go Maurer or Erasmo and Smoak (plus a mid level guy if needed), but not feeling one of the big 3. If I'm gonna give up Paxton and Smoak, I want Butler and another solid spec.
If all this is true, either they think Montero can handle 1st, or they plan on trading him. And the only person I would consider trading him for is Stanton and guys like that, and I don't see that happening
I would do Paxton and Montero for Butler and Myers tho.
I wouldnt trade Montero or Smoak. I wouldnt trade for Butler unless Montero is going to be our everyday catcher. And even then, Zunino is close to being ready. I just don't get it. I like Butler but don't see a fit. Unless he is cheap cause he is not enough of a upgrade over Smoak in my opinion. Not enough to give up one of the big 3 for sure.
I agree we need upgrade in the outfield. But to say Butler isnt an upgrade is ridiculous. I have some faith in Smoak, but I dont think its a guarantee that he improves.
I said before I dont really want to give up one of the Big 3. But Id go Erasmo or Maurer all day
would you go Erasmo, Vargas and Smoak for Butler and Felipe Paulino?
How sweet would Swisher/Hamilton and Butler be?
Sponsored Links |
|