Youk breaks down but he is a more productive hitter (a more appropriate for this team type of hitter) than Polly was. Polly broke down just as much, if not more, than Youk as well. Obviously I know the Phillies aren't going after Polly again but Youk is the kinda batter you can bat 2nd or 5th and be happy about it. A more 1 year plus an option or two wouldn't be a bad deal and like I said even a 2 year deal I'd be fine with. Anything more and another team can have him. I'm not sure what type of team would want him though considering his inury history. He's more of a filler type at this point which is what he'd be with the Phillies.
Headley is who everyone should want first though.