QB controversy thread

[25YrsNcounting]

He looked like recycled **** tonight.

[BDawk4Prez]

He looked like recycled **** tonight.

Surprised?

[25YrsNcounting]

Surprised?

Not really. He was set up to fail with that atrocious play calling. Having Kevin Kolb throw 50 times on the road against a division rival is dumb. Especially in a close game like that. He missed some big time plays that warrant no excuses, though.

[YEDN90]

In before sample size argument

[PhillySportFan]

Not really. He was set up to fail with that atrocious play calling. Having Kevin Kolb throw 50 times on the road against a division rival is dumb. Especially in a close game like that. He missed some big time plays that warrant no excuses, though.

Yeah I watched the first quarter and saw Kolb miss some throws that could have been TDs or big plays. I saw this morning he ended with 50 throws which is far to many but if he capitalized on them they could of ran it more in the 2nd half. As an Eagles fan you knew the Cardinals would only last as long as they have the lead in games, once behind there pretty much finished.

[last stand]

Didn't watch, can't watch lol. Looks like kolb played poorly. 28/50 not really a good percentage at all. Not really talented enough to throw that much. Only 4-5 qbs in the league should be allowed that number because I just dont think most qbs can even play well with that many throws given their talent. See Vick vs browns

[garnotm]

Yeah I watched the first quarter and saw Kolb miss some throws that could have been TDs or big plays. I saw this morning he ended with 50 throws which is far to many but if he capitalized on them they could of ran it more in the 2nd half. As an Eagles fan you knew the Cardinals would only last as long as they have the lead in games, once behind there pretty much finished.

That defense is set up to play with the lead. Good run defense and then they can pin back their ears and rush the qb. However I have to feel sorry for Kolb 17 sacks in 4 days...

[Tymathee]

i'm sick of vick, when he's aggressive he throws ints, when hes not he can't get down the field or get scores.

the dudes not a starting caliber QB, he's a great weapon but you can't go the distance with this guy, way too inconsistent.

We need to move him to a team that will give us something in the off-season, no SB for us this year.

[YEDN90]

Doubt we can move him, but I agree that I dont think Vick will be winning us a SB this year.

[BrianWestKins]

I won't be the guy to compare Vick's and Kolb's stats

[last stand]

I won't be the guy to compare Vick's and Kolb's stats

Well kolb obviously has a great line and WR corp, running game

Oh wait it's a crappy line, poor running game, and 1 superstar WR with some decent sidekicks

But ya Vick has excuses out the butt and kolb is still bottom feeding trash

[25YrsNcounting]

^^^ People need to stop treating Vick like the 2010 Vick. He's regressed at an alarming rate. Granted, he wasn't going to keep playing at that insane rate that he was then but his performance has regressed below his Atlanta days. It's a very big problem.

[strokeman]

ya'll wishes may come true
http://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com...snt-his-fault/

http://espn.go.com/nfl/story/_/id/85...terback-change

my take is, Andy and Marty is the problem, look at the games we win, McCoy has over 20 carries in all our wins, under 20 in all our losses. you would think we understand what needs to be done.
our Game Plan is just garbage!

[Teehar]

I might calm down with a win over the Saints but,atm I want Reid fired!

[last stand]

ya'll wishes may come true
http://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com...snt-his-fault/

http://espn.go.com/nfl/story/_/id/85...terback-change

my take is, Andy and Marty is the problem, look at the games we win, McCoy has over 20 carries in all our wins, under 20 in all our losses. you would think we understand what needs to be done.
our Game Plan is just garbage!

You have proof that Vick is a successful passer without Marty and Andy. Please share