The Trade Thread

[fanofphilly]

wow thats a GREAT trade...... if your getting Brees and Peterson


i hate veto's I feel when 2 ppl agree they should pass it regardless

[badkins1121]

Yeah. I was getting Brees and Peterson.

It had 3 vetos then a couple hours before it would of went through it got the 4th one so it went to the commish and he declined it.

Its an online league that my brother and I got into, if we all knew each other it probably woulda went through haha

[fanofphilly]

free / paid league?

do they know you two are brothers??

[badkins1121]

$100 12-team league.

They probably know we are related since our names our on there, there is two other guys that are related in the league too. One of them is the commish haha.

But literally every trade has at least gotten one objection, its kinda getting ridiculous

[fanofphilly]

yeah i would put the trade in again in my opinion...then i would start a thread explaining why you want to do it, then have your brother respond saying why he wants to do it


so people can see both point of views....


I hate when ppl veto... their just JELLY

[METSandJETS94]

I was offered Rob Gronkowski and Isaac Redman for Darren McFadden. Here's my team:

Philip Rivers
Carson Palmer

Darren McFadden
Adrian Peterson
Lagarette Blount
Brandon Jacobs
Ronnie Brown

Greg Jennings
Wes Welker
Reggie Wayne
Santonio Holmes

Jason Witten

I already said no, but do you guys think I should have done it? I like having 2 top 10 RB and Redman certainly isn't top 10. I see Redman more as a 3. I'd also have Jason Witten on my bench. Maybe after this deal I could have packaged Witten and Redman for a better RB? I don't know. I think I'm better leaving my team as it is.

[Boston-Born]

I was offered Rob Gronkowski and Isaac Redman for Darren McFadden. Here's my team:

Philip Rivers
Carson Palmer

Darren McFadden
Adrian Peterson
Lagarette Blount
Brandon Jacobs
Ronnie Brown

Greg Jennings
Wes Welker
Reggie Wayne
Santonio Holmes

Jason Witten

I already said no, but do you guys think I should have done it? I like having 2 top 10 RB and Redman certainly isn't top 10. I see Redman more as a 3. I'd also have Jason Witten on my bench. Maybe after this deal I could have packaged Witten and Redman for a better RB? I don't know. I think I'm better leaving my team as it is.

No way. You are wayy too light on RBs plus you already have a top 5 TE (even though he is going to miss the entire preseason). I would actually consider adding some RB depth since AP and DMac are injury concerns. I would also go handcuff them right now to be safe if you haven't yet.

[badkins1121]

I just got this offer. Passing TDs are 6 points everything else standard.

I Get: Drew Brees, Frank Gore, Darius Heyward-Bey, Pierre Thomas

I Give: Tony Romo, Marshawn Lynch, Greg Jennings

My current team...

QB: Romo, Flaaco
RB: R. Rice, Lynch, BJGE, Helu, Turbin, Scott
WR: Jennings, A. Brown, Meachem, Titus Young

I would obviously need to try to trade for better WR after but yeah haha

[levignjw]

I just got this offer. Passing TDs are 6 points everything else standard.

I Get: Drew Brees, Frank Gore, Darius Heyward-Bey, Pierre Thomas

I Give: Tony Romo, Marshawn Lynch, Greg Jennings

My current team...

QB: Romo, Flaaco
RB: R. Rice, Lynch, BJGE, Helu, Turbin, Scott
WR: Jennings, A. Brown, Meachem, Titus Young

I would obviously need to try to trade for better WR after but yeah haha

I'd prefer your team as is IMO

[fanofphilly]

pass on that one

[RaJAxTWa]

heres the trade that i got offered,

I give up Big Ben, Tate(he has foster) and Stevey
I get AJ Green and Titus Young

thoughts? imagine my starting lineup lol so tempting

P.S my team and league info is in my sig

[badkins1121]

yeah i would put the trade in again in my opinion...then i would start a thread explaining why you want to do it, then have your brother respond saying why he wants to do it


so people can see both point of views....


I hate when ppl veto... their just JELLY

Yeah so my trade of Romo, Ray Rice, Antonio Brown, Bernard Scott for Drew Brees, Adrian Peterson, Lance Moore, Toby Gerhart got vetoed.

Well this just went through in the same league...

RG3, Roddy White, McFadden for Brees, A. Peterson, Gerhart

[fanofphilly]

heres the trade that i got offered,

I give up Big Ben, Tate(he has foster) and Stevey
I get AJ Green and Titus Young

thoughts? imagine my starting lineup lol so tempting

P.S my team and league info is in my sig

most will say yes, but I say no. you are giving up 2 quality starters to get 1 in return. Granted Steve Johnson had an off year last year in terms of what we expected. Or is that just really who he is? I mean he almost looked identical in back to back years, but last year he had that injury....and plus his QB was injured in the middle of the year.. All that into play I think S.Johnson will be just as good as AJ Green this year....keep him and Big Ben. Dont give another team an advantage.

Yeah so my trade of Romo, Ray Rice, Antonio Brown, Bernard Scott for Drew Brees, Adrian Peterson, Lance Moore, Toby Gerhart got vetoed.

Well this just went through in the same league...

RG3, Roddy White, McFadden for Brees, A. Peterson, Gerhart

lol that trade is 50/50 i must say... its fair. In the other trade you were getting the better end of the deal....well ya win some ya lose some

[badkins1121]

^ Even that trade had 3 vetos. This league is just crazy with the vetoing its ridiculous. EVERY trade has had at least 2 votes against it i think haha

[Dol-Fan]

Holdout continues...I've been offered Jones-Drew in a keeper league for the 3rd overall pick. There are 10 teams, and I traded for all of my keepers this past year (Stafford, AJ Green, Britt, Stevie Johnson, Finley). My last 2 keepers suck, but since we keep 5 players, making this trade would mean losing value on a keeper + losing the 3rd pick.

Is it worth it for a player that's holding out and might underperform ala CJ2K last year? Should I ask for more or just decline? Thoughts?

I already own the 1st overall pick, 3rd, 9th 14th, 21, 41, 47, 55, 60, 61, 67 (did a lot of trading for top half picks last year)