Tim Duncan vs Lebron James - New Organization

[dee85]

Tim Duncan all day.

[LakersMaster24]

Tim Duncan.

Prime Timmy on those Lebron Cleveland teams, would have a pretty high chance to win a ring.

[todu82]

Lebron

[Raps08-09 Champ]

How is that any different from Lebron having Shaq or Ben Wallace or Wade guys who won titles a few years before and as the only allstar on the team and/or won 3 finals mvp's?

Are you comparing Shaq and Wallace during their Cleveland days to Robinson when he was first paired with Duncan?

[Jint.]

Timmy !

[Reversed86Curse]

Tim Duncan. Harder to find a big with his skill set than a power-guard with LBJs skill set

[rufo4100]

Slight edge to Duncan

[JordansBulls]

Honestly I've stopped caring to make a legitimate argument against JB. He just states random facts and acts as if his opinion is the norm.

Yeah but you don't make any argument at all.

[jerellh528]

The best PF of all time, or pretty much a poor mans oscar robertson? Gimme duncan.

[Lakersfan2483]

It is close, but I will take Duncan.

[JordansBulls]

The best PF of all time, or pretty much a poor mans oscar robertson? Gimme duncan.

In what way is Lebron a poor man's Oscar Robertson?

[KnicksorBust]

In what way is Lebron a poor man's Oscar Robertson?

Yeah that's a ridiculous statement.

I took Duncan because he's proven that he can win with another dominant big (Robinson) as a twin towers team AND he's won with quality (not elite) guards Manu-Parker.

It's easier knowing I can build either way and still get leadership, loyalty, and championships.

[Money_23]

I'd take Duncan because he did win in 03 and 05 with just an average roster.

[SteBO]

Love LeBron, but I'm going to have to take Duncan here. LBJ and Duncan were basketball prodigies coming into the league, but big men with Duncan's skillset don't come around often....

[SteBO]

You can't go wrong here either way though.....