I was beginning to do this around January but I felt it would be a much better idea to do so in the off-season, when people won't be judged by one game and such.
Which all of the lists being mentioned, I think we should do our own, and prove how difficult it truly is. We'll do it kind of slow, and do ten of these.
#1 - #10
#11 - #20
etc.
Basically I'll leave this open for two days, and we do a points standing to gather our top 10, and go to the next round.
Everyone that misses the top ten, no matter how few points they missed by, will be eligible for the next round (10 picks).
Tie-breaker will be decided later.Example
Guy 1:
1) Pavel Datsyuk [10 points]
2) Alexander Ovechkin - [9 points]
3) Sidney Crosby - [8 points]
4) Tim Thomas - [7 points]
5) Zdeno Chara - [6 points]
6) Evgeni Malkin - [5 points]
7) Steven Stamkos - [4 points]
8) Jonathan Toews - [3 points]
9) Henrik Sedin - [2 points]
10) Daniel Sedin [1 point]
Guy 2
1) Sidney Crosby [10 points]
2) Alexander Ovechkin [9 points]
3) Jonathan Toews [8 points]
4) Pavel Datsyuk [7 points]
5) Evgeni Malkin [6 points]
6) Henrik Lundqvist [5 points]
7) Zdeno Chara [4 points]
8) Nick Lidstrom [3 points]
9) Steven Stamkos [2 points]
10) Henrik Sedin [1 point]
Guy 2, also posts the current standings
1) Alexander Ovechkin [19P]
2) Sidney Crosby [18P]
3) Pavel Datsyuk [17P]
4) Evgeni Malkin [11P]
5) Jonathan Toews [11P]
6) Zdeno Chara [10P]
7) Tim Thomas [7P]
8) Steven Stamkos [6P]
9) Henrik Lundqvist [5P]
T10) Henrik Sedin [3P]
T10) Nick Lidstrom [3P]
-------------------
11) Daniel Sedin [1P
If you don't add in the points, + the standings, your vote will not count.
.A Few Rules/Reminders
1. Adding points and such, like I mentioned above
2. Double check your numbers for errors. If you spot someone else with an error, please post it
3) Try not to be too much of a homer and/or hater.
4) If there's a reason why a notable guy is so low, please mention. For Example; Crosby's injury. That's fine.
5) Please don't bash these players over and over
6) If I see a list, with like an Edmonton fan having RNH at #1, your list will not count. Simple as that
7) Let's try and value goaltenders and defenseman too
8) No talkback in here
Nicklas Lidstrom will not be included.
PSD's Top 100 Players: 1-10Top 100 Players (These players cannot be taken again)
1. Sidney Crosby, C
2. Evgeni Malkin, C
3. Pavel Datsyuk, C
4. Steven Stamkos, C
5. Claude Giroux, C
6. Zdeno Chara, D
7. Henrik Lundqvist, G
8. Alexander Ovechkin, W
9. Jonathan Quick, G
10. Shea Weber, D
11. Jonathan Toews, C
12. Henrik Sedin, C
13. Pekka Rinne, G
14. Daniel Sedin, W
15. Nicklas Backstrom, C
16. Anze Kopitar, C
17. Ilya Kovalchuk, W
18. Ryan Suter, D
19. Martin St. Louis, W
20. Tim Thomas, G
21. Duncan Keith, D
22. John Tavares, C
23. Marian Hossa, W
24. Erik Karlsson, D
25. Jarome Iginla, W
26. Corey Perry, W
27. Patrick Sharp, W
28. Henrik Zetterberg, C
29. Joe Thornton, C
30. Chris Pronger, D
PSD's Top 100 Players: 11-20
PSD's Top 100 Players: 21-30
I'll begin (this is mine)
31. Loui Eriksson [10]
32. Jason Spezza [9]
33. Eric Staal [8]
34. Ryan Getzlaf [7]
35. Kris Letang [6]
36. Dan Boyle [5]
37. Rick Nash [4]
38. Carey Price [3]
39. Drew Doughty [2]
40. Phil Kessel [1]
Standings
31. Loui Eriksson [10]
32. Jason Spezza [9]
33. Eric Staal [8]
34. Ryan Getzlaf [7]
35. Kris Letang [6]
36. Dan Boyle [5]
37. Rick Nash [4]
38. Carey Price [3]
39. Drew Doughty [2]
40. Phil Kessel [1]