Rate The Importance of Each QB Stat

[NormSizedMidget]

Passing Yards
Completion %
Yards/Attempt
Touchdowns
Interceptions
TD%
INT%
Passer Rating
Record
Playoff Record
Super Bowl Wins
Clutchness
Rushing/Mobility

[NormSizedMidget]

Yards/Attempt
INT%
Completion %
Passer Rating
TD%
Super Bowl Wins
Passing Yards
Touchdowns
Intereceptions
Record
Clutchness
Rushing/Mobility

[TearsOfPurple]

On a scale of 1-10:

Passing Yards - 4
Completion % - 7
Yards/Attempt - 10
Touchdowns - 7
Interceptions - 7
TD% - 8
INT% - 8
Passer Rating - 7
Record - 6
Playoff Record - 5
Super Bowl Wins - 0
Clutchness - 7
Rushing/Mobility -6

[NormSizedMidget]

I should have TD:INT ratio. I didn't think of it.

I stole this thread idea but tweaked it a lot.

[BigBlueCrew]

Passing Yards -- 3
Completion % -- 5
Yards/Attempt -- 3
Touchdowns -- 3
Interceptions -- 3
TD% -- 3
INT% -- 3
Passer Rating -- 6
Record -- 8
Playoff Record -- 8
Super Bowl Wins -- 8
Clutchness -- 10
Rushing/Mobility -- 0

[NormSizedMidget]

Clutchness -- 10

I was going to joke that every Giants fan would put this at 10 lol

I guess it wasn't a joke.

[BigBlueCrew]

I was going to joke that every Giants fan would put this at 10 lol

I guess it wasn't a joke.

Of course I (personally) would put it at ten. You dont have to lump every Giants fan in with me. But I guess that's what you do.

Whats the point of accumulating stats if you cant come thru when the team needs you *cough*Tony Romo*cough*

[TheVicster]

Sooooooooooooo.............

SB wins are important, but SB losses aren't?

To be clear, neither means squat IMHO because they're team, not individual ones.

But if wins mean something, then losses must too.

Or does it not matter that someone has 5 wins and75 losses?

[NormSizedMidget]

Of course I (personally) would put it at ten. You dont have to lump every Giants fan in with me. But I guess that's what you do.

Whats the point of accumulating stats if you cant come thru when the team needs you *cough*Tony Romo*cough*

Let's not let this get personal. I just kind of giggled when I saw clutchness.

I don't personally think Romo is the huge choke artist others do but certainly in sports being clutch does exist. I've said before I feel like Dallas is the perfect team atmosphere for choking. I think NYG has been a group that's always rallied together. You always felt like they were going to do it somehow. In Dallas is always how are they going to **** this up. And I don't feel that's totally something that comes from Romo.

I don't find Rodgers incredible clutch yet he won a SB, SB MVP, and MVP so maybe that's why I don't rate it that high.

[NormSizedMidget]

Sooooooooooooo.............

SB wins are important, but SB losses aren't?

To be clear, neither means squat IMHO because they're team, not individual ones.

But if wins mean something, then losses must too.

Or does it not matter that someone has 5 wins and75 losses?

Well I suppose both are important but not that much. I didn't really think of this thread on my own.

[TheVicster]

Passing Yards -- 3
Completion % -- 5
Yards/Attempt -- 3
Touchdowns -- 3
Interceptions -- 3
TD% -- 3
INT% -- 3
Passer Rating -- 6
Record -- 8
Playoff Record -- 8
Super Bowl Wins -- 8
Clutchness -- 10
Rushing/Mobility -- 0

Sooooooooo.......all of the team stats are more important, and all of the individual stats are less important........Brilliant!

[subroc]

In order of importance (1-7):

Passing Yards (4)
Completion % (1)
Yards/Attempt
Touchdowns (5)
Interceptions (2)
TD-INT% (7)
Passer Rating (3)
Record (6)
Playoff Record
Super Bowl Wins
Clutchness
Rushing/Mobility

[Pinstripe power]

on a scale of 1-10

Passing Yards - 4
Completion % - 7
Yards/Attempt - 6
Touchdowns - 8
Interceptions - 9
TD:INT - 9
TD% - 7
INT% - 8
Passer Rating - 7
Record - 0
Playoff Record - 0
Super Bowl Wins - 0
Clutchness - 5
Rushing/Mobility - 3

[NormSizedMidget]

How can you put TDs>TD%

It makes no sense.

It's like putting Yards over Yards Per Attempt

[Pinstripe power]

How can you put TDs>TD%

It makes no sense.

It's like putting Yards over Yards Per Attempt

let me see if I have this right. TD% is the precentage of your throws that are TDs right? so like cam newton for example, whould get a bit skewed there because of rushing TDs and what not. thats what i was thinking. did the same thing for interceptions because i though it said turnovers to include fumbles