Is Starlin Castro a top 3 short stop in the MLB?

[theguruisback3]

Simple question.

I vote no.

[Jeffy25]

no

[NY_Heartbreak]

1. Tulo
2. Jose Reyes
3a. Asdrubal Cabrera
3b. Starlin Castro

IMO

[ilstubirds]

So this is just a Yes/No question with no list of who the 3 are and why?

That's simple then.

Yes.

[long ball]

no

[Chi~TwnHawksFan]

to me, and im a Cubs fan WOO, but anyways, to me he is on the fence of top 3. Simply because of his errors

[Jamiecballer]

no absolutely not. he doesn't have the plate discipline or enough pop at this point in time.

[theguruisback3]

Not enough pop in his bat? He hit 10 homers last year, and will hit around 15 this year. That's good enough for a SS.

I don' think he's top 10 but it has everything to do with his low OBP, not how much pop is in his bat.

[VRP723]

Right now no, but he's damn good

[CubbieSteve]

Not yet. Only 22, he'll hold his spot down for a long time soon enough.

[sixers247]

^ Not top ten? Didn't make a list so you could be right but i think that's a little low.

[theguruisback3]

^ Not top ten? Didn't make a list so you could be right but i think that's a little low.

I meant top 3, my fault.

[sixers247]

Ok makes more sense lol.

[ahoda]

Definitely not top 3, but has the potential to be there. I don't know if he will put it all together though.

[RedHeadsRule]

Probably not.

Tulo belongs in his own category. I think Elvis is a little better now, but in their primes, I think Starlin will surpass because of his offensive upside. I'd probably also take Reyes and Asdrubal over him as well. So maybe 5th?