Donovan McNabb a Hall of Famer?

[NBA_Guru_51]

Donovan McNabb a Hall of Famer? He says "absolutely," but I'm not so sure

[whitesoxfan83]

no

If Cris Carter isn't a 1st/2nd ballot HOF then this guy isn't a HOF period.

[rapjuicer06]

Cris Carter is robbery. I am completely disgusted that they tainted his career by ****ing him over this badly. Best hands EVER. Best sideline receiver EVER. Ridiculous.

But McNabb...I'd say its debatable. I personally lean towards yes though, but I think its foolish for McNabb to say that

[j11430]

Had he not gone to Washington and Minnesota, I'd say sure. But he showed everyone that Andy Reid was the guy that made him good, not himself. I wouldn't vote him in

[bhooks80]

Donovan McNabb is delirious. Never could capitalize on opportunity. Just like the Eagles of his time period.

[surf and turf]

i say no. He had a ton of talent. I just think he was never a good west coast QB. Not that he didnt do well in the system. It just seemed like he wasnt accurate enough for a lot of the playbook.

[bhooks80]

Chris Carter is borderline HOF. I would not vote for him.

Not a spectacular receiver IMO. Great player, just not one I would tell my grandkids about.

[ManningToTyree]

Chris Carter is borderline HOF. I would not vote for him.

Not a spectacular receiver IMO. Great player, just not one I would tell my grandkids about.

Carter is 100% a HoFer.

Mcnabb I say no. Good player, never reached greatness.

[da ThRONe]

i say no. He had a ton of talent. I just think he was never a good west coast QB. Not that he didnt do well in the system. It just seemed like he wasnt accurate enough for a lot of the playbook.

Who?

I was just going to say other than Tom Brady Donovan has done more with less than any other QB in recent memory.

[bhooks80]

Carter is 100% a HoFer.

actually currently he is 0% HOF.

[da ThRONe]

Cris Carter is robbery. I am completely disgusted that they tainted his career by ****ing him over this badly. Best hands EVER. Best sideline receiver EVER. Ridiculous.

But McNabb...I'd say its debatable. I personally lean towards yes though, but I think its foolish for McNabb to say that

Why is it foolish to say he think he belongs? Is he supposed to say he isn't worthy?

[The Final Boss]

Tim Brown and a slew of others deserve a nod before this clown. No, I don't believe he is anywhere near a HOFer.

[mp3]

Not a HOF. McNabb was an above average QB for Philly. He had one great season. He thinks he is a HOF because he reached 5 NFC Championships and his stats are good. He says Dan Marino made the HOF without a ring so he should too. This guy is completely delusional.

[stephkyle7]

I watched Donovans career rather closely for not being an eagles fan ,and you Could count on him EVERY year to have 3 or 4 games where he inexplicably played like he was on crack, balls flying all over the place,misreading defenses, it was like a different guy out there. For that reason alone I wouldnt put him in.Everyone has a bad game once in a while but this was like clockwork,and he would never recover. That 4th and 26 to Freddy was something special though....

[bigbangclock]

i think he is a near miss.excellent stats,kept interceptions to a minimum,played with a few iffy recievers during his peak but he stumbled after leaving the eagles and i think that will really hurt him in voters memories of his career.