Prime Gary Payton
I love cp3... but I'm going with Gary. He can shut down the opposing team's best perimeter player and still give you 22, 9 and 5 on a pretty good clip shooting.
If they were playing head to head, I mean its hard not to pick Payton. He's got the speed and size to guard CP better than any other pg in the NBA today. Then offensively, people forget that Gary was a great post player.