I used several advanced and traditional #'s..You using carmello was a bit flawed
Lets look at best seasons..
Carmelo has 2 yrs of WS's above 8.5
Iverson has 6 seasons of WS's above 9.0
They both have the same WS/48 and if you compare both at the age of 27? Iverson>Carmello
Overall though, They arn't far off. People overrate Iverson due too making the finals in one of the weakest confrences of all time. Give carmello Mutumbo and Mcke/Snow as 2 solid role guys they make the NBA finals in that conf also.
Iverson was simply marketed too death/played in a pretty big sports town/and was flashy. Does ANY of that translate into actual production? HECK NO! I take NONE of that into consideration. Most people assume Kobe>Duncan..When I firmly believe Duncan>Kobe..
Another example KG being as washed up as he was last season was still more productive than a guy like Blake Griffin..even though most people thought just that, Kg was washed up and though Griffin was some superstar
Last edited by Bos_Sports4Life; 03-04-2012 at 06:26 PM.