Eli manning where do you rank him

[raiderfaninTX]

So its all over eli is a champion so I want to know where does he rank
for you

Approach this if you were building a team how may qb's would you choose in front of him

I have him 4th if his brother was healthy hed be 5th

so for me

Brady
rodgers
brees
eli

if peyton is healthy put him where eli is and eli would be 5th

[Luxy312]

Top-10. Assuming PM comes back, there's him, Rodgers, Brees, Brady, Romo, and Stafford. Eli is after that grouped with the likes of Rivers and Ryan.

[xxplayerxx23]

Anybody could put him anywhere, Idc anymore he is top 5 to top 6. Call him average I could care less two time superbowl MVP, GMEN!!!!

[Embryo]

Better than Big Ben.

Better than Brady (post Brady full season injury where Cassel replaced him)

Better than every QB in the NFC East.

Better than Phil Rivers.

Not better than Rodgers because of Rodgers's body build.

I say he's TOP THREE

[xxplayerxx23]

Top-10. Assuming PM comes back, there's him, Rodgers, Brees, Brady, Romo, and Stafford. Eli is after that grouped with the likes of Rivers and Ryan.

romo and stafford over eli? And no big ben?

[bosox3431]

Better than Big Ben.

Better than Brady (post Brady full season injury where Cassel replaced him)

Better than every QB in the NFC East.

Better than Phil Rivers.

Not better than Rodgers because of Rodgers's body build.

I say he's TOP THREE

Brady's worst season since the injury, 09, would be Eli's best season of his career.

[bosox3431]

If building a team:
Rodgers
Brady
Brees
Rivers
Romo
Ben
Stafford
Eli

That's entirely based on building a team. Not necassarily who's better.

[Greet]

Top 5-6

If PManning is healthy, it's between him and Ben for 5. I'd give the nod to Ben.

[WadeKobe]

Top 5-6

If PManning is healthy, it's between him and Ben for 5. I'd give the nod to Ben.

Come on, co. Get your head in the game.

[Greet]

Come on, co. Get your head in the game.

Oh?

[WadeKobe]

Oh?

7-8 with Rivers.

[GGGGG-Men]

Top-10. Assuming PM comes back, there's him, Rodgers, Brees, Brady, Romo, and Stafford. Eli is after that grouped with the likes of Rivers and Ryan.

Romo and Stafford ahead of Eli? I can't imagine building a team and taking Romo over Eli. They both put up good numbers, but I want the guy who wins when I need him to.

Stafford? I don't even know how that works. Unless he automatically comes with Megatron, no way.

So its all over eli is a champion so I want to know where does he rank
for you

Approach this if you were building a team how may qb's would you choose in front of him

I have him 4th if his brother was healthy hed be 5th

so for me

Brady
rodgers
brees
eli

if peyton is healthy put him where eli is and eli would be 5th

I agree with that. Definitely take a healthy Peyton ahead of Eli.

[FortDetroit]

romo is better than eli....

and i'm actually a bigger eli fan than most non-new yorkers.

[yankeefan54]

Better than Big Ben.

Better than Brady (post Brady full season injury where Cassel replaced him)

Better than every QB in the NFC East.

Better than Phil Rivers.
Not better than Rodgers because of Rodgers's body build.

I say he's TOP THREE

Brady since his injury has put up better numbers year after year brady is better still eli hasnt had one season better or even close to any of bradys top 5 seasons.

[krisxsong]

If building a team:
Rodgers
Brady
Brees
Rivers
Romo
Ben
Stafford
Eli

That's entirely based on building a team. Not necassarily who's better.

If I'm rebuilding a team this is my order.

Rodgers
Stafford
Big Ben
Rivers
Brees
Brady
Eli
Romo