Tom Brady

[joe good]

Im a Lions fan so its not a "homer question"

If Brady win a 4th Super Bowl ..would he be considered by many the Greatest QB to ever play the game ?

Its rare to see a QB to have as much success in the regular season AND in the post season.

[NickGB]

Uhm, he can never win another Super Bowl and still be in discussion by many as one of the greatest's to play the game. So I would assume if he won another one it would just seal the fate and be a done deal. The guy is just simply an incredible player.

[FortDetroit]

He's the best QB I have ever seen play. Even better than Sam Bradford.

[utl768]

another patriots thread? and to answer the question no

not in this era where the defensive rules have been dumbed down so much

[NormSizedMidget]

another patriots thread? and to answer the question no

not in this era where the defensive rules have been dumbed down so much

lol, you're not biased against Brady though.

If he wins again, especially this year........man that would be something.

The rules changing doesn't make it easier to win SB's, everyone is playing with the same rules.

[joe good]

another patriots thread? and to answer the question no

not in this era where the defensive rules have been dumbed down so much

Sorry ..i dont have anything to say about Sanchez .....

[lolPhillies]

I like Brady but definitely not.

[joe good]

I like Brady but definitely not.

yeahh 49 ers fan ..i knew you would say something like that

[Ebbs]

If he wins again and plays very well in the postseason yea I would give it some thought. I already consider him top 5 all time.

[long ball]

I think he's in the conversation now. Another one or two super bowls which is possible only helps his case.

[MacFitz92]

Depends on a lot of things, but I think you'd have to look at his overall body of work during his career versus the likes of Montana, Unitas, Marino, Elway, Manning, etc.

[Mudvayneowns91]

I think some already do. If he did win again, I mean it would certainly make it that much harder to disagree.

As far for me, I just group all the all time greats in cause it's hard to compare with different time periods. He's definitely there with Montana, Elway, Marino, Manning etc. to me.

[SportsAndrew25]

He is already one of the top five QBs in NFL history. Three Super Bowls, a near perfect season and could win a fourth this year.

[joe good]

and i think he's got the best ratio TD-INT and Wins-losses ever for a QB

[billsftw]

another patriots thread? and to answer the question no

not in this era where the defensive rules have been dumbed down so much

so THAT explains why Sanchez is doing so well