He's borderline.
Simple question: Yes or no?
Yes
No
He's borderline.
Simple question: Yes or no?
Sixers / Packers / Flyers / Phillies
Sponsored Links |
|
As a Packers fan I say no. Jersey wont be retired but he will certainly be in the Packers HOF...
Chris Carter isn't even in the HOF... Let's be real
No... if he does it will take a while. Look at guys like Chris Carter. Then you have all these players putting up insane stats and he will go overlooked. Like Ochocinco has 1,000 more yards in 2 less seasons.
Receiver is a tough position to get in as.
What happens if he wins another ring?
Sixers / Packers / Flyers / Phillies
Has he ever been a top 5 WR? Not even close to HOF IMO.
NE Patriots Forum HOF (Class of 2011)
My roommate and I had a debate. I'm a Packers fan and I said no but he, a Broncos fan, said yes with enthusiasm.
Sixers / Packers / Flyers / Phillies
Sponsored Links |
|
I like him and looking at his career #s they're better than I thought. But I just never looked at him as a top 5 WR in the NFL. He's consistant and had a pretty long stretch of being a great WR, but he was never a truly elite player and I think you need to be to get into the HOF. Classic case of "Hall of Very Good" for me.
NE Patriots Forum HOF (Class of 2011)
On google search, when you type in "Donald D" ....his name comes before Donald Duck... HOF material.
Sixers / Packers / Flyers / Phillies
Compared to Art Monk, He's about 3,000 yards, 11 TDs, one Super Bowl (Monk played in 2 of the 3 victories during his time with Washington) and a little more than 200 receptions away from having a career similar to Monk. Do I think it'll happen? No. Is it possible? ehhh.. sure..
Sixers / Packers / Flyers / Phillies
Packers HOF.
If I facepalmed any harder I would have cracked my own skull.
Sponsored Links |
|