Are they a HOFer?

[tev_dodd]

My opinions, no research.

- Wes Welker- Yes
- Donovan McNabb - Yes
- Frank Gore- No
- Chad OchoCinco- No
- Reggie Wayne- Yes
- Eli Manning- No
- London Fletcher- No, but one of the most underrated players ever
- Jay Cutler- No
- Matt Schaub - No
- Brian Urlacher = Yes
- Antione Winfield - No
- Adrian Wilson- No
- Darren Sharper- Yes

I might have been too generous, but oh well

[spinalcracker]

Welker - Not yet. But will make his way in with a few more seasons like this or a superbowl MVP.
McNabb - Tough call. I say no but everybody will say yes.
Gore - No
OchoCinco - No
Wayne - No
Eli Manning - Yes
Fletcher - Yes
Cutler - No
Schaub - Not right now.
Urlacher - Yes
Winfield - No
Wilson - No
Sharper - Yes

[semmler11]

- Wes Welker yes
- Donovan McNabb no
- Frank Gore not sure
- Chad OchoCinco not sure
- Reggie Wayne yes
- Eli Manning yes
- London Fletcher yes
- Jay Cutler no
- Matt Schaub no
- Brian Urlacher yes
- Antione Winfield no
- Adrian Wilson yes
- Darren Sharper yes

[NJBASEBALL22]

Welker- No, started too late and no enough TD's
McNabb- I'd say yes but he is borderline
Gore- No, great RB but never stood out as one of the best
Ochocinco- Borderline, overall no, he didn't last long enough and rubbed ppl the wrong way.
Wayne- Yes, but borderline, Ochocinco was better but Wayne was more consistent.
Eli Manning- Too early to tell but if he keeps this up
Fletcher- Yes, so underrated
Cutler- Haha
Schaub- No, not a top QB, just very good
Urlacher- Yes
Winfield- No
Wilson- No
Sharper- Yes, he has the numbers, the rep, and the SB

If I'm voting (and I hate Eli)- I say McNabb, Wayne (but who knows w/ Cris Carter still waiting), Eli, Fletcher, Urlacher, and Sharper get in.