Are they a HOFer?

**ManningToTyree** · 09-01-2011, 01:15 PM

Originally Posted by Realistik84

Assuming they play out the rest of their career, staying on course with their production to date, are the following HOFers?

(I tried to stay away from the obvious and identify some that may be arguable, and tried to focus on those who "played" 6 years or so)
(I am not saying they are/not by listing them)

- Wes Welker- no
- Donovan McNabb- no
- Frank Gore- no
- Chad OchoCinco- maybe
- Reggie Wayne- yes
- Eli Manning- no
- London Fletcher- yes
- Jay Cutler- no
- Matt Schaub- no
- Brian Urlacher- yes
- Antione Winfield- maybe
- Adrian Wilson- no
- Darren Sharper- yes

there you go.

**Giants #1 Fan** · 09-01-2011, 01:31 PM

- Wes Welker - No
- Donovan McNabb - Maybe, but doubt it
- Frank Gore - No
- Chad OchoCinco -Maybe but doubt it
- Reggie Wayne - Yes, but not right away
- Eli Manning - No
- London Fletcher - No, but he deserves it
- Jay Cutler -

- Matt Schaub - No
- Brian Urlacher - Yes...Probably second ballot
- Antione Winfield - No, If he'd had more Ints he would
- Adrian Wilson - No
- Darren Sharper - No, even though numbers say he should

**theheatles** · 09-01-2011, 01:36 PM

Sharper, Urlacher and Reggie Wayne...YES

**Pinstripe power** · 09-01-2011, 01:38 PM

- Wes Welker - no
- Donovan McNabb - tough one, but i think no
- Frank Gore - no
- Chad OchoCinco - no
- Reggie Wayne - yes
- Eli Manning - no
- London Fletcher - no (he gets snubbed for everything else, why not here too)
- Jay Cutler - no
- Matt Schaub - no
- Brian Urlacher - yes
- Antione Winfield - no
- Adrian Wilson - no
- Darren Sharper - yes

**Bravo95** · 09-01-2011, 01:47 PM

McNabb, Wayne, and Sharper may have to wait a long time. Urlacher will get his call early.

**xM1GSx** · 09-01-2011, 06:28 PM

urlacher.

**Yendil** · 09-01-2011, 06:39 PM

Originally Posted by Saddler The Gr8

people are voting no for Mcnabb? lolwut?

look at McNabb, he is not great nor HOF caliber without westbrook/staley and Philly's screen game. When your RB is the teams leading reciever year in and year out and you still can not post 60% completion that does not indicate you are a good QB. His RATE+ (which is not QB Rating) is 106, 100 is league average. He is slightly above average in his career even with his RB's and screen production.

**Saddler The Gr8** · 09-02-2011, 03:16 AM

Originally Posted by Yendil

look at McNabb, he is not great nor HOF caliber without westbrook/staley and Philly's screen game. When your RB is the teams leading reciever year in and year out and you still can not post 60% completion that does not indicate you are a good QB. His RATE+ (which is not QB Rating) is 106, 100 is league average. He is slightly above average in his career even with his RB's and screen production.

he's had TRASH WR's his whole career, except the 2 with TO.

**Sphinn** · 09-02-2011, 04:00 AM

Only one that gets in for sure is Urlacher.

The only other guys that might get in are Wayne and Sharper.

I think no for Wayne because there is already a huge back log of WRs, so if he does make it it's not going to be for a long time.

Sharper I wouldn't have a problem with but Safeties are overlooked when Canton comes calling. You really have to be head and shoulders above everyone else to make it.

As for McNabb, nice career but no Super Bowl trophy means no way for most QBs.

**Cal827** · 09-02-2011, 04:13 AM

Originally Posted by Realistik84

Assuming they play out the rest of their career, staying on course with their production to date, are the following HOFers?

(I tried to stay away from the obvious and identify some that may be arguable, and tried to focus on those who "played" 6 years or so)
(I am not saying they are/not by listing them)

- Wes Welker- Probably Not
- Donovan McNabb- Yes
- Frank Gore-

- Chad OchoCinco- Possibly
- Reggie Wayne- Yes
- Jay Cutler-

- London Fletcher- Possibly
- Eli Manning-

- Matt Schaub- Probably not
- Brian Urlacher- First Ballot
- Antione Winfield- ???
- Adrian Wilson- Maybe
- Darren Sharper- Yes

A lot of these guys (Including Cutler/Manning) have their best years ahead of them though. McNabb/Sharper seem close to the end of their respective careers and both appear to be HOFs (at least IMO)

**WolvesJagsOs** · 09-02-2011, 09:57 PM

Not sure why Cutler is on the list, Urlacher, Wayne, Fletcher, Sharper, McNabb i could all see getting in.

**Zetterberg40** · 09-03-2011, 02:03 AM

I'd give Sharper and Urlacher the ok to as well as McNabb but I dont think McNabb will get in and Sharper is a toss up although Urlacher is not near a 1st ballot he deserves it and IMO will get it

**Ebbs** · 10-11-2011, 01:06 PM

- Wes Welker - No
- Donovan McNabb - No
- Frank Gore - No
- Chad OchoCinco - No
- Reggie Wayne - No
- Eli Manning - Yes
- London Fletcher - No
- Jay Cutler - No
- Matt Schaub - No
- Brian Urlacher - Yes
- Antione Winfield - No
- Adrian Wilson - No
- Darren Sharper - Yes

I tried to go with who I think will get in not who I think should.

**cwick925** · 11-20-2011, 10:43 AM

Urlacher and thats it.

**bullTitan** · 11-23-2011, 10:15 AM

Give Cutler an Oline and he could do something to get in that class. Hard to throw the ball with 300 pound guys sitting on your head.

Urlacher should be in the day he retires.

All this I ain't even a Bears fan.

Thread: Are they a HOFer?

Thread Tools

Display

Posting Permissions