Bigger impact: Manny or Fuentes?

[tommyboy]

obviously manny is the bigger name of these acquisitions but his numbers have definitely seen a decline in the past few years. he's no griffey to the sox like last year but at 38 can he produce like the chisox need him to? fuentes has been decent as a closer but has proven that he is not ideally suited for the role. however as a 7th and 8th inning set up man he man be able to provide a depleted twins bullpen the left handed help that it needs.

[Reversed86Curse]

Personally, I tend to think that added pitching is a bigger boost than hitting (outside of a team that has no bats, which the W.Sox aren't) in the post season, so Fuentes

[todu82]

Fuentes