Halladay>Lester (slighty, lester is damn good)
Oswalt<Buchholz (look at the stats, no lie, its not even that close.. especially with clay pitching in the al east all year and oswalt pitching in the nl central for majority.. i mean come on)
Hamels=Beckett (maybe.. if beckett is right he is way better)
Kendrick<Lackey (Lackey having a down year but not that down.. kendrick isnt good anyway and would get rocked in the al east)
blanton<dice-k (blanton ****ing blows.. and people hate on dice-k despite his 45-24 career record and his career era 4.00, about 1/2 a run less than blanton, and his whole career has been in the al east...)
Honestly this isnt even close. The Red Sox is so much better than the Phillies. Put the Phillies rotation in the AL East and there wouldn't even be a reasonable debate.. Not that it is reasonable anyway....