Anyone else think Brett Gardner is a legit superstar in the making?

[nymetsrule]

Superstar? No.

Good player? Probably...

[DodgerBlue8188]

he's just a fast white boy j/k

[MelanconMadness]

Not even in the slightest. Hell never be an allstar, let alone be a star, or superstar. He's better than melky, that's all that matters

[redwhitenblue]

Not even in the slightest. Hell never be an allstar, let alone be a star, or superstar. He's better than melky, that's all that matters

He's a Yankee, he has a legit shot at an AS game someday simply because of that.


But seriously, it's a hot start. He'll have a couple nice years of .300/.375/.375 years, but outside of that, he's extremely replacable. A nice 4th or 5th OF. Solid defense and a very good baserunner for late in games.

[MelanconMadness]

He's a Yankee, he has a legit shot at an AS game someday simply because of that.


But seriously, it's a hot start. He'll have a couple nice years of .300/.375/.375 years, but outside of that, he's extremely replacable. A nice 4th or 5th OF. Solid defense and a very good baserunner for late in games.

Actually most people vote against yankee players. The only mainstays (that are voted in) are teix, and jeter. And possibly cano now. But other than that, no one else really gets voted in. And ARods problem last year means he won't be anymore either

And I doubt gardner ever hits over .285 (which for a 9th hitter is perfectly fine with me).

[NYMETS2889]

OMG YES! oh wait did you say superstar? no not a chance

he has a juan pierresque career ahead of him, and thats not a bad thing just not a superstar

[nyyfan4life]

Solid everyday player: Sure
Superstar: No

[Gigantes4Life]

Actually most people vote against yankee players. The only mainstays (that are voted in) are teix, and jeter. And possibly cano now. But other than that, no one else really gets voted in. And ARods problem last year means he won't be anymore either

And I doubt gardner ever hits over .285 (which for a 9th hitter is perfectly fine with me).

Most people don't vote against Yankee players, since most people are either Yankee fans, Yankee band-wagoners or really don't know the difference.

But I definitely see what you're saying.

[GOON MUSIC]

SUPERSTAR !!!

lmaoo, maybe a good piece

[dvda 89]

Superstar? not even close .. He has surprised me how solid of a player he is though.

[Marlins97and03]

Superstar????????

are you kidding Me??

solid player = Best case Scenario

[TheRuckus]

Yeah...that .377 BABIP is going to regress. Plus he's not even slugging .400 right now. But he'll be a quality player, thanks to his patience, speed, and glove.

[mdlr52192]

Giants99 in the MLB forum too huh?

[infernoscurse]

only if he sings ghetto superstar with mya & pras replacing ol'dirty bastard

ghetto superstar

that is what you areeee

coming from above , reaching for the starrrrsssss

[1-800-STFU]

Well, you do have Kotsay doing his best job there!

I hate you.