2009 Redraft for Wide Receivers

[Giants99]

The eagles actually only threw the ball 11 more times than the giants this year so essentially they pass the ball about the same amount. the eagles also do spread the ball around more than NY. it's kind of silly to try to say which WR is better when they are so comparable after just 1 year in the league.

that doesnt mean that they played the exact same number of passing plays as WRs. Nicks was not a guy who was always on the field during passing plays

[G-Menfan4lyfe]

i can tell this is going to become a homer fest.

[momoneyyyy]

louis murphy is way better than dhb for the guys who dont know...

[LegendX]

I took into account overall performance throught the entire season, versatility, and supporting cast.

1 - Percy Harvin

Receptions: 60
Yards: 790
Avg: 13.2
TDs: 6
Yds Per Game: 52.7

Rush Att: 15
Yards: 135
Avg: 9.0

Kick Returns: 42
Yards: 1156
Avg: 27.5
TDs: 2

2 - Hakeem Nicks
(Ability to be a #1 WR)

Receptions: 47
Yards: 790
Avg: 16.8
TDs: 6
Yds Per Game: 56.4

3 - Jeremy Maclin

Receptions: 55
Yards: 762
Avg: 13.9
TDs: 4
Yds Per Game: 50.8

4 - Kenny Britt

Receptions: 42
Yards: 701
Avg: 16.7
TDs: 3
Yds Per Game: 43.8

5 - Austin Collie

Receptions: 60
Yards: 676
Avg: 11.3
TDs: 7
Yds Per Game: 42.2

6 - Michael Crabtree
(Ability to be a #1 WR)

Receptions: 48
Yards: 625
Avg: 13
TDs: 2
Yds Per Game: 56.8

7 - Mike Wallace

Receptions: 39
Yards: 756
Avg: 19.4
TDs: 6
Yds Per Game: 47.2

Rush Att: 5
Yards: 48
Avg: 9.6

8 - Mohammed Massoquoi
(Ability to be a #1 WR)

Receptions: 34
Yards: 624
Avg: 18.4
TDs: 3
Yds Per Game: 39

9 - Brian Hartline

Receptions: 31
Yards: 506
Avg: 16.3
TDs: 3
Yds Per Game: 31.6

Rush Att: 4
Yards: 29
TDs: 1

10 - Johnny Knox

Receptions: 45
Yards: 527
Avg: 11.7
TDs: 5
Yds Per Game: 35.1

Kick Returns: 32
YardsL 927
Avg: 29
TDs: 1


Just Missed Out: Louis Murphy.

[LegendX]

i can tell this is going to become a homer fest.

Does my list make me look like a homer?

[G-Menfan4lyfe]

to legend X:

nice job coming up with all that

[G-Menfan4lyfe]

Does my list make me look like a homer?

not at all and u still managed to get hartline on it!

good job with ur research tho, u really put it into perspective.

[LegendX]

not at all and u still managed to get hartline on it!

good job with ur research tho, u really put it into perspective.

WRs are my forte, I guess. Lol.

If anyone disputes it, they can see my sig, or I'll just explain. Lol.

[The GEEEEE Men]

true. watch those lil giants fan moan and ***** about it.

stop baiting


I'll go

1) Harvin (easily)
2) Nicks
3) Maclin
4) Crabtree
5) Wallace
6) Collie (although Manning makes any WR look good)
7) Britt
8) Murphy
9) Knox
10) Massaquoi

[Dogers101]

that doesnt mean that they played the exact same number of passing plays as WRs. Nicks was not a guy who was always on the field during passing plays

Well that's cuz he was not good at catching the ball, how many times does he drop the ball in a game? Lol. It's funny giants fans were yapping about nicks having the best hands known 2 mankind.

[roshan3ai]

Well that's cuz he was not good at catching the ball, how many times does he drop the ball in a game? Lol. It's funny giants fans were yapping about nicks having the best hands known 2 mankind.

I'm guessing that the only game that you saw was the Eagles game, and you didn't see that after those two drops, he came back with a touchdown and burned your defenders. If you actually watched Nicks play, he doesn't drop too many passes.

[roshan3ai]

I took into account overall performance throught the entire season, versatility, and supporting cast.

1 - Percy Harvin

Receptions: 60
Yards: 790
Avg: 13.2
TDs: 6
Yds Per Game: 52.7

Rush Att: 15
Yards: 135
Avg: 9.0

Kick Returns: 42
Yards: 1156
Avg: 27.5
TDs: 2

2 - Hakeem Nicks
(Ability to be a #1 WR)

Receptions: 47
Yards: 790
Avg: 16.8
TDs: 6
Yds Per Game: 56.4

3 - Jeremy Maclin

Receptions: 55
Yards: 762
Avg: 13.9
TDs: 4
Yds Per Game: 50.8

4 - Kenny Britt

Receptions: 42
Yards: 701
Avg: 16.7
TDs: 3
Yds Per Game: 43.8

5 - Austin Collie

Receptions: 60
Yards: 676
Avg: 11.3
TDs: 7
Yds Per Game: 42.2

6 - Michael Crabtree
(Ability to be a #1 WR)

Receptions: 48
Yards: 625
Avg: 13
TDs: 2
Yds Per Game: 56.8

7 - Mike Wallace

Receptions: 39
Yards: 756
Avg: 19.4
TDs: 6
Yds Per Game: 47.2

Rush Att: 5
Yards: 48
Avg: 9.6

8 - Mohammed Massoquoi
(Ability to be a #1 WR)

Receptions: 34
Yards: 624
Avg: 18.4
TDs: 3
Yds Per Game: 39

9 - Brian Hartline

Receptions: 31
Yards: 506
Avg: 16.3
TDs: 3
Yds Per Game: 31.6

Rush Att: 4
Yards: 29
TDs: 1

10 - Johnny Knox

Receptions: 45
Yards: 527
Avg: 11.7
TDs: 5
Yds Per Game: 35.1

Kick Returns: 32
YardsL 927
Avg: 29
TDs: 1


Just Missed Out: Louis Murphy.

Good work, but I would like to know why Crabtree was so low

[G-Menfan4lyfe]

Well that's cuz he was not good at catching the ball, how many times does he drop the ball in a game? Lol. It's funny giants fans were yapping about nicks having the best hands known 2 mankind.

I think its funny that desean jackson was yapping on twitter about the cowboys being scared of him and he got shut down in all 3 games they payed this season.... lol, now thats funny, just like TBS

[Dogers101]

I'm guessing that the only game that you saw was the Eagles game, and you didn't see that after those two drops, he came back with a touchdown and burned your defenders. If you actually watched Nicks play, he doesn't drop too many passes.

u know if asante samuel knew how to tackle nicks would not have been that LUCKY. btw lets not get in2 a argument about burning defenders, lol.

[Dogers101]

I think its funny that desean jackson was yapping on twitter about the cowboys being scared of him and he got shut down in all 3 games they payed this season.... lol, now thats funny, just like TBS

yeah that was funny. but whats funny is desean "action" jackson burning the giants every single game. lol.