Now, I don't think this thread will do anything to sway minds one way or the other. Brady fans will use the rings and team accomplishments, while Manning fans will use the individual stats and performances. I believe Peyton is better than Brady, and absolutely hate it when people say "oh look what Brady did with weapons in 2007." Fact of the matter is, Brady in 07 had MUCH more than Manning did in 04, and Peyton still had a considerably better season. If Brady supporters can use the 07 season, then Manning supporters can use the 04 season, where Manning did more with alot less. THis article helps that argument.
It's pretty long, but it explains perfectly why one season was better than the other and why the "look what Brady does with weapons" argument is invalid, since Peyton has done better with less.