I still argue with Volunteer fans that Charles Woodson was the better player in college and his gamebreaking plays won him the Heisman. Many people are going to choose Peyton over Charles.
Woodson won a National Championship.
Manning won a Super Bowl.
As much as I urk @ Green Bay, maybe it can be finished in the Super Bowl this year.
I'd still rather have Charles Woodson over Peyton Manning and I'd take it any day of the week. Yes, Manning is a dominating QB, the position is in his blood, but could he beat Vandy? Ryan Leaf was JUST as GOOD....remember.
You can't compare Woodson to anybody. If you want to say Terry Fair, I will laugh at you. The nice, retired, Terry Fair.
Who would you rather have, for you, your team and your community, Charles Woodson or Peyton Manning?