2009 Redraft for Wide Receivers

[roshan3ai]

If you could pick the order that the wide receivers in the 2009 draft were drafted, how would you choose?

For me it would be:

1. Michael Crabtree

2. Hakeem Nicks

3. Percy Harvin

4. Jeremy Maclin

5. Kenny Britt

6. Mike Wallace

7. Austin Collie

8. Johnny Knox

9. Mohamed Massaquoi

10. Louis Murphy

11. Darrius Heyward -Bey

[SB75]

I'm guessing you are a giants fan. No other way is Nicks ahead of Maclin and Harvin.

1. Crabtree

2. Harvin

2A. Maclin

4. Nicks

5. Britt

6. Bay ( I know he was horrible, but the QB was worse)

7. Massaquoi

8. Murphy

[North Yorker]

Harvin has to be 1 or 2, thats for sure.

And you are missing Mike Wallace.........

[wildfan7]

1-Harvin
2-Hakeem Nicks
3-Michael Crabtree
4-Jeremy Maclin
5-Mohamed Massaquoi
6-Louis Murphy
7-Kenny Britt
8-Darrius Heyward -Bey

[Thatruth32]

crab
harvin
louis murphy
nicks
maclin

[asmarks18]

1. Wallace
2. Crabs
3. Harvin
4. Maclin
5. Nicks
6. Britt
7. Murphy
8. Massaqioi

[slaker619]

1.Harvin
2.Hakeem
3.Crabtree
4.Murphy
5.Massaquoi
6.Britt
7.Darrius Heyward-Bay
8.Maclin

[Young2Kinsler]

1. Harvin
2. Nicks
3. Crabtree
4. Britt
5. Maclin
6. Wallace
7. Murphy

Meh to the rest

[EaglesJackson10]

1.Harvin
2.Hakeem
3.Crabtree
4.Murphy
5.Massaquoi
6.Britt
7.Darrius Heyward-Bay
8.Maclin

[AIsixersFK]

1. Michael Crabtree

2. Percy Harvin

3. Jermey Maclin

4. Hakeem Nicks

5. Mike Wallace

6. Kenny Britt

7. Darrius Heyward -Bey

8. Mohamed Massaquoi

9. Louis Murphy

10. Austin Collie

Hayward-Bey deserves another opportunity but I still think he has potential

[Giants99]

I'm guessing you are a giants fan. No other way is Nicks ahead of Maclin and Harvin.

Why? Because every Eagle player is "The BeSt EvEr DooD"?


Nicks has shown the ability to get a lot of YAC.

The stats are very similar for Harvin, Nicks, Britt, and Maclin except Nicks and Harvin have a lot more TDs. Crabtree gets penalized from me for the antics he pulled.

1. Percy Harvin (assuming he keeps his head on straight)
2. Hakeem Nicks
3. Micheal Crabtree
4. Kenny Britt
5. Jeremy Maclin
6. Mohamed Massaquoi
7. Louis Murphy
8. DHB

[Dogers101]

1.Harvin
2.Hakeem
3.Crabtree
4.Murphy
5.Massaquoi
6.Britt
7.Darrius Heyward-Bay
8.Maclin

[roshan3ai]

I'm guessing you are a giants fan. No other way is Nicks ahead of Maclin and Harvin.

1. Crabtree

2. Harvin

2A. Maclin

4. Nicks

5. Britt

6. Bay ( I know he was horrible, but the QB was worse)

7. Massaquoi

8. Murphy

Well Hakeem Nicks played one less game and accumulated the same yardage as Harvin. They had the same number of touchdowns, and late in the season Nicks became a main target for Eli. Given that Harvin is a threat in the kick return game, I think that this is a tossup, and you are entitled to your own opinion.

As for Maclin, Hakeem Nicks had eight more yards, and two more touchdowns in one less game. Maclin was also the second option for the eagles most of the year, which means more targets. Hakeem was only promoted to the second wideout spot during the shootout against the Eagles in the meadowlands.

[Dogers101]

Why? Because every Eagle player is "The BeSt EvEr DooD"?


Nicks has shown the ability to get a lot of YAC.

The stats are very similar for Harvin, Nicks, Britt, and Maclin except Nicks and Harvin have a lot more TDs. Crabtree gets penalized from me for the antics he pulled.

1. Percy Harvin (assuming he keeps his head on straight)
2. Hakeem Nicks
3. Micheal Crabtree
4. Kenny Britt
5. Jeremy Maclin
6. Mohamed Massaquoi
7. Louis Murphy
8. DHB

[Dogers101]

Well Hakeem Nicks played one less game and accumulated the same yardage as Harvin. They had the same number of touchdowns, and late in the season Nicks became a main target for Eli. Given that Harvin is a threat in the kick return game, I think that this is a tossup, and you are entitled to your own opinion.

As for Maclin, Hakeem Nicks had eight more yards, and two more touchdowns in one less game. Maclin was also the second option for the eagles most of the year, which means more targets. Hakeem was only promoted to the second wideout spot during the shootout against the Eagles in the meadowlands.

eagles have JACKSON who is the number 1 and then u go to Celek (just under 1000 yards and 8 TDs) then its maclin. btw i love nicks so called HANDS (eagles game) .lol