Trevor Ariza vs. Wilson Chandler

[kozelkid]

Whose better?
I think it's Ariza

[madiaz3]

Chandler is more suited to be a 1st option player, as Ariza can't create his own shot nearly as well as Chandler.

Both are explosive finishers, Ariza is a better three point shooter, Chandler better at creating off the dribble, both great slashers, both are great defenders.

Depends on the need, with Kobe and Gasol, you wouldn't need infact you'd prefer for Ariza to expend the majority of his energy on defense while Chandler is needed to score a whole lot more and thus is a better fit for the Knicks.

And considering Chandler's second season was practically his rookie season, (Isiah Thomas didn't like to play him much...) with ~600 minutes the first season versus ~3000 minutes the next, Chandler has a ton of upside.

[kozelkid]

Chandler is more suited to be a 1st option player, as Ariza can't create his own shot nearly as well as Chandler.

Both are explosive finishers, Ariza is a better three point shooter, Chandler better at creating off the dribble, both great slashers, both are great defenders.

Depends on the need, with Kobe and Gasol, you wouldn't need infact you'd prefer for Ariza to expend the majority of his energy on defense while Chandler is needed to score a whole lot more and thus is a better fit for the Knicks.

And considering Chandler's second season was practically his rookie season, (Isiah Thomas didn't like to play him much...) with ~600 minutes the first season versus ~3000 minutes the next, Chandler has a ton of upside.

I wouldn't exactly call chandler a first option... As d'antoni said, he is like the marion for the knicks. Both are very similar imo. Both very explosive and athletic as you mentioned and very good defenders. However would benefit the most from a very good creator and an offensive, fast paced offense. You can't forget, chandler scored more points mainly by playing a more fast paced system where he got more minutes and was a higher option. Personally I'd say it's very close, but ariza does have the experience and every now and then chandler would take a dumb shot (at least from what I have seen when knicks played the bulls).

[kanersen]

i'd take ariza, simply because he's a better on the ball defender, off the ball defender and a better 3 point shooter

chandler's the better rebounder and scoring option, but if i'm asking either to be a major scoring option, my team is already in trouble

both are relatively equal in value though

[m26555]

Chandler is more suited to be a 1st option player, as Ariza can't create his own shot nearly as well as Chandler.

Both are explosive finishers, Ariza is a better three point shooter, Chandler better at creating off the dribble, both great slashers, both are great defenders.

Depends on the need, with Kobe and Gasol, you wouldn't need infact you'd prefer for Ariza to expend the majority of his energy on defense while Chandler is needed to score a whole lot more and thus is a better fit for the Knicks.

And considering Chandler's second season was practically his rookie season, (Isiah Thomas didn't like to play him much...) with ~600 minutes the first season versus ~3000 minutes the next, Chandler has a ton of upside.

Nope.

Ariza shot 61-of-191 from three this year (31.9%) while Chandler shot 103-of-314 (32.8%).

Chandler is also a much better FT shooter (79.5% compared to 71% for Ariza).

[Sports Illustrator]

Right now, Trevor Ariza is definitely the better player and has helped the Lakers reach the finals. However, like in 1 or 2 years from now, this won't be a comparison. I am expecting Wilson Chandler to become a much better player and should be a set starter coming into the season. I agree with those you mentioned him as being a more complete player than Ariza.

[IBleedPurple]

Chandler is more suited to be a 1st option player, as Ariza can't create his own shot nearly as well as Chandler.

Both are explosive finishers, Ariza is a better three point shooter, Chandler better at creating off the dribble, both great slashers, both are great defenders.

Depends on the need, with Kobe and Gasol, you wouldn't need infact you'd prefer for Ariza to expend the majority of his energy on defense while Chandler is needed to score a whole lot more and thus is a better fit for the Knicks.

And considering Chandler's second season was practically his rookie season, (Isiah Thomas didn't like to play him much...) with ~600 minutes the first season versus ~3000 minutes the next, Chandler has a ton of upside.

[DODGERS&LAKERS]

Chandler is more suited to be a 1st option player, as Ariza can't create his own shot nearly as well as Chandler.

Both are explosive finishers, Ariza is a better three point shooter, Chandler better at creating off the dribble, both great slashers, both are great defenders.

Depends on the need, with Kobe and Gasol, you wouldn't need infact you'd prefer for Ariza to expend the majority of his energy on defense while Chandler is needed to score a whole lot more and thus is a better fit for the Knicks.

And considering Chandler's second season was practically his rookie season, (Isiah Thomas didn't like to play him much...) with ~600 minutes the first season versus ~3000 minutes the next, Chandler has a ton of upside.

Ill take your word for it since you watch a lot of Ariza and Chandler. I have not seen enough of Chandler to make an unbiased post

[_Sn1P3r_]

I agree. ^ Very good post.

[Kakaroach]

This is a close one but I go with Ariza.

[29$JerZ]

Ariza is a better 3 pt shooter, and perimeter defender. Also good at gambles and stealing in the passing lane.

Wilson is more along the lines of a Shawn Marion, can do everything except get assist.

I'll say Ariza as of now, and Wilson in the next 2 years. Hard to comptete with someone in the semi finals and playing with Kobe.

[superkegger]

I said ariza, but I really haven't seen enough of Chandler.

[MiamiHeat]

I would pick Ariza but for the Heat I would pick Chandler because he could create his own shot and it gives us another scoring option

[Duncan = Donkey]

chandler will be alot better than ariza in the future

[Kakaroach]

chandler will be alot better than ariza in the future

x2 Yea, that is what will prolly happen. Chandler has a good future.