J. Kidd Hall of Fame worthy?

[Hoopsadvocate]

Jason Kidd is a great play maker and overall player, but is he Hall of Fame worthy at this point in his career? The main question im asking is if J Kidd never gets a ring do you think he should make the Hall of Fame?

[RealistRocket34]

How is this even a question? There is no discussion about this

http://www.basketball-reference.com/...ob_career.html
49. Jason Kidd 0.9845

I'm really surprised Dirk has a higher % than J-Kidd though.

[The Panch]

Jason Kidd will be in the hall as soon as he is eligable, no question about it.

[kvrnm]

kidd is a hall of famer with ease

[VCaintdead17]

easily

[Hoopsadvocate]

How is this even a question? There is no discussion about this

http://www.basketball-reference.com/...ob_career.html
49. Jason Kidd 0.9845

I'm really surprised Dirk has a higher % than J-Kidd though.

But theres a discussion about Yao > all NBA centers right?

Anyways that reference has T mac on 98% chance of getting HoF which i think is ridiculous so that shows it credibility.

I'm just up in the air about whether Kidd should be in the Hall or not. 3-4 years ago i would have said sure but he never got a ring and unlike some who haven't (Reggie, Ewing, Barkley) he had help (Nowitzki, jefferson, martin, Mutumbo) and unlike someone else who had help and didnt didnt get a ring (Malone and Stockton) they at least made consecutive finals appearences and i think many would agree that if it wasnt for Jordan they would have at least 1.

[RealistRocket34]

What does Yao have to do with it? What is your opinion then?

All I am saying is there is not much of a debate. Jason Kidd is easily a hall of famer, a ring would just make his greatness better.

[mcnasty54]

j-kidd will get in the hall of fame has soon as possible

[Hoopsadvocate]

What does Yao have to do with it? What is your opinion then?

All I am saying is there is not much of a debate. Jason Kidd is easily a hall of famer, a ring would just make his greatness better.

My opinion like i said is that im not sure at this point true a ring would make his greatness better, but i just think that one of the credentials to get into the Hall should be a ring with only very few exceptions made like consecutive finals appearences, or a crazy amount of all NBA first team elections. All im saying is that Hall is getting a little crowded and J Kidd is like the perfect example of where to draw the line...

[theuuord]

um,


duh?

[RealistRocket34]

My opinion like i said is that im not sure at this point true a ring would make his greatness better, but i just think that one of the credentials to get into the Hall should be a ring with only very few exceptions made like consecutive finals appearences, or a crazy amount of all NBA first team elections. All im saying is that Hall is getting a little crowded and J Kidd is like the perfect example of where to draw the line...

Jason Kidd is starting to get underrated in the league and I feel bad because I felt like he was an overrated player before the season started. He makes a bunch of nobodies like Mikki Moore, James Singleton and Erick Dampier actual somebodies in the league, and he made them while he is declining.

J-Kidd is a lock for HOF, You could even argue he is the GOAT PG, though I wouldn't.

Anyways, what's your take on Yao since you brought him up.

[Lakerfrk]

How is this even a question? There is no discussion about this

http://www.basketball-reference.com/...ob_career.html
49. Jason Kidd 0.9845

I'm really surprised Dirk has a higher % than J-Kidd though.

Am I blind, or is Dwayne Wade not on that list?

[RealistRocket34]

Am I blind, or is Dwayne Wade not on that list?

I think you need to be in the league for a certain amount of years before you could qualify for HOF. I think one more year for him because Yao Ming and Amare Stoudemire are on there.

[Sportfan]

easily he will make it no doubt about it

[Hoopsadvocate]

Jason Kidd is starting to get underrated in the league and I feel bad because I felt like he was an overrated player before the season started. He makes a bunch of nobodies like Mikki Moore, James Singleton and Erick Dampier actual somebodies in the league, and he made them while he is declining.

J-Kidd is a lock for HOF, You could even argue he is the GOAT PG, though I wouldn't.

Anyways, what's your take on Yao since you brought him up.

I dont think those 3 guys are anymore somebodies with kidd than when before without kidd lol. Oh an Yao is alright i guess probably the best mid range shooter at the C position (unless u count duncan) but i feel like hes a bit soft. At that height and with his skill he shouldn't be getting outscored and rebounded by 6'11 ish D Howard or any C nice guy though nothing but respect for Yao.