Who's not in the Hall Of Fame that should

[TheRedMarauder]

And looking at it 2010 will be another tough year for some of these players to get induction. Jerry Rice, Emmit Smith, Tim Brown and Aeneas Williams all become eligible.

[MT3279]

I hate to say it, but I think Tim and Aeneas are going to be snubbed for a bit while the bottlenecking continues.

I think ya'll know how much I love the old school NFL...I really think both Senior Committee nominees should be inducted every year, instead of just being named finalists.

[MT3279]

MT with the smackdown on the HOF committee. I say MT for the HOF.

We've discussed this before...I would love to have a vote in that room.

When will Randy be eligible for the Senior Committee voting, btw?

[pantherfan89]

jerry rice or sam mills or sean taylor when ever he is able to go in

[TheRedMarauder]

I hate to say it, but I think Tim and Aeneas are going to be snubbed for a bit while the bottlenecking continues.

I think ya'll know how much I love the old school NFL...I really think both Senior Committee nominees should be inducted every year, instead of just being named finalists.

If Tim is snubbed then so should Cris and Andre. No way should those guys get in before Tim, he should be ahead of them in the WR pecking order.

And just yesterday I was checking up on some numbers and you know who I think deserves more consideration than Reed, yet hasn't even gotten a sniff from the HOF? Henry Ellard, the only reason Reed gets more press is because he played for that Bills team that was loaded.

Ellard has more career yards on less catches. He led the league in ypc at 35 years of age. And look at his 1994 season, I don't think there's ever been a 1400 yard WR that has had to catch passes from such a horrendous trio of QB's and with basically no running game.

[TheRedMarauder]

jerry rice or sam mills or sean taylor when ever he is able to go in

As much as I love Sean Taylor he's not getting into the HOF. He didn't play enough.

[MT3279]

If Tim is snubbed then so should Cris and Andre. No way should those guys get in before Tim, he should be ahead of them in the WR pecking order.

And just yesterday I was checking up on some numbers and you know who I think deserves more consideration than Reed, yet hasn't even gotten a sniff from the HOF? Henry Ellard, the only reason Reed gets more press is because he played for that Bills team that was loaded.

Ellard has more career yards on less catches. He led the league in ypc at 35 years of age. And look at his 1994 season, I don't think there's ever been a 1400 yard WR that has had to catch passes from such a horrendous trio of QB's and with basically no running game.

Yeah, I agree about Ellard, I just hate him because he caught a good portion of those yards against the Saints.

[Hermie2011]

Chris Carter

[AntiG]

Roger Craig

[bagwell368]

Fred Smerlas

Ben Coats

[MT3279]

Fred Smerlas

Ben Coats

He and Culp are the two best NTs ever (Pure 3-4 NTs, not MG like Willis played). I completely agree with you here.

[steelcityroller]

About half of the players mentioned in here belong in the Hall of Good not the Hall of Fame.

[henderson56]

Jim Marshall

[themadstork]

Ray Guy is the most egregious omission from any Hall of Fame...anywhere.

-Stork

[mchl_wrrn]

What about Derrick Thomas??? He changed the game.
Also Sharpe, Carter, should be first ballots-the voters didn't get this right.