Kurt Warner for HOF

[Nakamura25]

no way, he was a product of a very well oiled system. although I would say his numbers in that system were good enough so as to say he was a good player too, just not HoF calibre.

[QuietWyatt]

no way

[titanlegend20]

I don't think he will. If he got in then McNair should go in since hes better.

[chicagoman1]

No he didnt play long enough

[Red_Sox_89]

I had this discussion with my cousin last night, so I looked up Kurt Warner and found this. In my opinion, he is a Hall of famer. As crazy as it may sound.

http://blogs.mercurynews.com/49ers/2...hall-of-famer/

[op12]

2 mvps and a SB champion, I would have to say yes even though he has been inconsistent.

[cowboysforlife]

As soon as I read the post my gut said Young is in so you have to put Warner in. Looking at the stats I had no idea how good the guy is. I think he has to go in.

[Red_Sox_89]

As soon as I read the post my gut said Young is in so you have to put Warner in. Looking at the stats I had no idea how good the guy is. I think he has to go in.

Yeah, that's why I started the thread. I don't think most people know how good he is throughout his career. In my opinion, his first year eligible, he's going in. You can't really say no to him

[Jaji]

I say yes, but not a first ballot HOFer. He's done some pretty remarkable things. And you have to love his story.

[cowboysforlife]

Alright guys i think that it needs to be asked, his career is much shorter than most of the guys we think of as HOF guys like Elway, Marino, Young, Montana. But he was for his ERA one of the best, and of course lead the Greatest Show on Turf. This is a tough debate because of his impressive stats for the time he played.

G      Comp     Att      PCT       YD       Y/A     TD      INT
77     1614     2463     65.5     20130     8.2     124     83

Source: Pro-Football-Reference

I suggest showing his stats compared to HOFer Steve Young. Aso might be good to add that he's got a league MVP, SB MVP and SB win.

[carson005]

Its not that he hasn't played long enough. Its that he hasn't played GOOD long enough.

No to HOF

[dbroncos78087]

I suggest showing his stats compared to HOFer Steve Young. Aso might be good to add that he's got a league MVP, SB MVP and SB win.

Wow, i posted that almost two years ago.

[TheRedMarauder]

Its not that he hasn't played long enough. Its that he hasn't played GOOD long enough.

No to HOF

I would have to agree. He was great from 1999-2001 and has had renaissance since the 2nd half of last year, but there's a 5 year gap in his career when he wasn't even a starter for much of that time.

[TheRedMarauder]

I suggest showing his stats compared to HOFer Steve Young. Aso might be good to add that he's got a league MVP, SB MVP and SB win.

Young has 7 Pro Bowls to Warner's 3, although he'll probably get a 4th this year. Young has 2 league MVP's and has likewise won 1 Super Bowl and an SB MVP. Young's record as a starter is 94-49, 91-33 if you discount his tenure with those horrible Bucs team. Warner's record is 48-37.

Young has about 7000 more yards than him passing plus over 4200 yards rushing and 43 rushing TD's and his passer rating is above Warner's.

[cowboysforlife]

Wow, i posted that almost two years ago.

Wow....that was weird. I started out posting in the NFL forum and then somehow ended up in here in the HOF forum... Got to lay off the Scotch.