Deron Williams vs Amare Stoudemire - New Franchise

[JordansBulls]

http://www.prosportsdaily.com/forums...d.php?t=273886

Similar to the above thread,


If you were starting a new team, who would you take or would rather have between these two guys?


Deron Williams vs Amare Stoudemire - New Franchise

[$KnicksAndKobe$]

Deron Williams without a doubt ...

He is a perfect PG who can do it ALL at point
Amare is great but without pickNroll Nash we don't know how much his stats will suffer (not saying Amare sucks without Nash, he is a beast with or without)

[Wilson]

I normally always go with the big guy. Amare is dominant on offense, but weak on defense, so I'd take Williams because he can play great on both sides of the floor.

[23LBJCleBrowns]

This is a hard one, I need to go with a point guard, Deron Williams.

[RapsGuy23]

Tough tough choice. I chose Amare simply because I like the idea of building a team around a big (for rebounding/interior defense/post etc). In this case I don't think one player is more valuable than the other I would just rather build a team around a big than a pg for the reasons I stated in the bracket above. I think Amare has the potential to improve his defense, which at times is average at best. If he can become an premier defender Amare could carry a team to an nba championship IMO.

I also thing Dwill is a franchise player. I luv his game, period.

[JMan17]

In the other thread i usually always go with the big guy, but Amare is only Dominate on Offense, his defense is weak. Also his rebounding is not really good as well.

I have to say Deron. Not only because of his skills, but he is arguably better then cp3.

[MiamiHeat]

In the other thread i usually always go with the big guy, but Amare is only Dominate on Offense, his defense is weak. Also his rebounding is not really good as well.

I have to say Deron. Not only because of his skills, but he is arguably better then cp3.

I normally always go with the big guy. Amare is dominant on offense, but weak on defense, so I'd take Williams because he can play great on both sides of the floor.

wow
almost the same thing lol
but anyways yeah if STAT was better defensively I'll go with him
but ill take DWill

[PhxOakFan3220]

is this a serious question it's amare without a doubt

[JMan17]

is this a serious question it's amare without a doubt

lol, of course coming from a suns fan.

[_Sn1P3r_]

I'd take Deron.

[oshea225]

i'd go with deron, no disrespect to amare. deron to me seems to be a better leader, better all around, younger, and amare has more help surrounding him then deron. i wouldnt complain with amare though, of course haha

[UofA]

Deron Williams, dominating point guard with size that is extremely skilled on both sides

[SensandRaps]

deron williams

[IversonIsKrazy]

hard 2 find a great pg in d-will who Is still under 25.

[Beno7500]

Tough...

Umm, probably Amare