Best Pitcher of All-Time

[lavell12]

Thought I'd make one poll for pitchers to.

[phlp_bj]

nolan ryan, cy young, greg maddux

[lavell12]

nolan ryan, cy young, greg maddux

I agree b/c what Maddux did as a non power pitcher in the steroid generation is amazing. Now with Roger caught he will atleast go down as the best pitcher of his generation. Just look at his ERA.

I voted for Ryan but without injuries Kofax might be the winner.

[- Gyro -]

I'll say Cy Young..because well, it's called a Cy Young award for a reason.

[J$mo0th_3o5]

Nolan Ryan

[bagwell368]

Ryan and Glavine are laughable at the head of any all time pitching list.

Given RC's place is unclear at the moment I'll go in order:

WJ
Grove
Clemens
RJ
Maddux
Alexander
Gibson

for career value.

for peak value and excellence per inning its:

Pedro
Koufax

and nobody else is in the ball park

[lavell12]

Ryan and Glavine are laughable at the head of any all time pitching list.

Given RC's place is unclear at the moment I'll go in order:

WJ
Grove
Clemens
RJ
Maddux
Alexander
Gibson

for career value.

for peak value and excellence per inning its:

Pedro
Koufax

and nobody else is in the ball park

How is Ryan laughable? 7 career no hitters and by far the most Ks of all-time. Glavine is like the third winningest lefty and probably the most underrated guy on the list. I'm not saying he is number 1 I just need enough guys to make out a full 15.

[ugafan]

Ryan is laughable, the most overrated baseball player of all-time.

Give me Koufax

[- Gyro -]

I'll still take Cy Young.

[mawp]

Different era's, too hard to compare without some stats.

[nstachowski]

Bobby Gibson, Baby!

[Kinsm]

Walter Johnson

[pimpunleashed]

Nolan Ryan

[ShinobiNYC]

1- Koufax
2- Pedro
3- RJ
4- WJ
5- Seaver

Great job forgetting Seaver btw(only 3 CY and twice finished 2nd)

[ShinobiNYC]

A good way to compare: http://www.baseball-reference.com/le..._leagues.shtml