I got offered a trade of a swap of a probowl wr for a probowl wr:

Me: Andre Johnson

Them: Torry Holt

Now, it's fantasy here. Not who you want in the next 10 years.

Andre Johnson:

He gets injured alot. What can I say. He doesn't have much help around him, so he will get doubled alot, but he will still be a probowler if healthy.

Torry Holt:

Injury problems again, but not as severe by any cause as Andre. He is alot older though, and Bruce is gone now. However, teams have to focus on other players other than Torry, so it's not like there going to be doubling him all the time either. He will be a probowler more than likely if he doesn't get injured.

I don't know what to do here. I know it's basically a win-win, but I have so many close fantasy games all the points count.

So would you do this trade or not?