Grady Sizemore vs. Josh Hamilton

[friarfan07]

i say grady, even though josh is having a better year so far. grady's a year younger and a better fielder. though i really like josh. ah hell i'm voting for josh cuz i like him better.

[SportsFan1988]

I would rather have Grady, all around he is the better player IMO, and still hasn't even reached his full potential...he's a player to REALLY look at in the future.

[letsgorangers27]

gradys a better all-around player. you cant base your opinion on someone cause of the hr derby

[viktor06]

I'll go with Josh, because of service time. Other than that, they are both absolute monsters

[sanfranfan1210]

Grady

[Webslinger]

Josh is the more exciting hitter. He doesn't just hit home runs he smashes them.

[Brooke]

Grady, he is a better all around player. Josh will be a great player, you can't judge a player on just how they hit the ball

[IndiansFan337]

Hamilton is the superior offensive player, by a good margin.

Sizemore is the superior defensive player. And Sizemore is younger, and without any risk.

With that being said, I'd probably take Hamilton, although he is a much bigger risk. He's just too valuable to pass up right now.

[Tragedy]

Sizemore has more room to grow, as he's still so damn young.

But as of RIGHT now, Hamilton is probably the superior offensive player.

[PhillyLuver]

Sizemore, I do love Hamilton though

[sixers247]

Sizemore, tough choice though.