I'd take Roy Halladay, only because he's pitched 6 more complete games than Cliff Lee. While that's not necessarily a good thing and it has mostly to do with when the manager decides to pull him, it shows that he's able to pitch deep into a game without getting tired. That's important if the bullpen has been overworked the previous few days and needs a day off.
Yeah for anyone whos just looking at their records or something... Halladay has been unbelievable this year.
He hasn't allowed more than 5 runs in any game this year, and his 7 CG is crazy... His record should be so much better than it is, he threw a CG and took the loss in 3 straight games I think (Apr. 17-29)... He should be 15-3, at least, if our team didn't suck so bad at scoring runs.
Halladay in a heart beat. Cliff lee will come back down to earht after the break.
Halladay = Always consistent throughout his career.
Lee = Kind of an abnormal moment for him right now. If he keeps it up and this becomes the type of pitcher he is the rest of his career, cheers to him. But I don't see that as a real possibility.